Isareli aerial defense system

永远老李
楼主 (文学城)

Aerial defense system is not new. During cold war, both America and Russia developed some kind of system to protect their cities and important military targets. China once imported Russian missle system to intercept Taiwan high attittude reconnaisance plane in 60s. But it was Isarel used American defense system Patriot missle to protect Isarel cities from Iraqi SCUD missle attack in the first Gulf War in 1991. It worked quite well. 

It seems Isarel uses new Iron Dome system purchased from France instead of from Uncle Sam. I guess the basic principle remains the same: a system to detect incoming weapon from air and send the info to own actual counter attack missile to intercept the warhead in the air. From video clips on media, it appears the system worked well. It did hit the targets in mid air. 

However there is an issue for this approach: the system is designed to destroy high value weapon such as missile from enemy which is accurate, powerful and dangerous. I don't think it is designed for crappy, low budget and small capacity rockets. It is simply not cost effective. It is somehow like using tank canon to shoot mosquitos. Of course you can easily blow up the tiny insect into peices but it is awfully expensive. In the recently Hamas attack, vast majority of Isareli casuality came from armed ground assaults. It is not caused by those rockets. It seems those flying rockets are only for show. It looks spectacular but it barely do anything. 

Anyway, I guess lots of military experts and scientists are watching this conflict closely. You can only know the true value of weapon system in actual combat. Mid East has been a great weapon test site for long period of time. 

 

盈盈一笑间
谢谢科普。占位点赞。回头细看。:)
移花接木
There's safety in numbers. WWII, German tankers said one
移花接木
One Tiger tank can take down 10 American Sherman tanks
移花接木
But the American can always have the 11th Sherman
方外居士
Think about the Great Wall. It never stopped invasion
r
renqiulan
When it comes to national defense, it is not all or nothing.
r
renqiulan
In real life, and especially in a real war, we use
r
renqiulan
what we have. We improvise and, hopefully, improve going
r
renqiulan
forward.Ditto our enemies. Let's see who will come ahead.
移花接木
Under saturated attack the efficiency'll be compromised
移花接木
But not Hamas can't sustain
r
renqiulan
We can and must count on our ingenuity and audacity.
7
7grizzly
Girls hated the GW: one wrecked it by crying at it,
方外居士
Sugar daddy?
7
7grizzly
吴三桂
移花接木
French Maginot Line, WWII
方外居士
哈哈哈,恸哭六军皆缟素,冲冠一怒为红颜!
方外居士
Right!
7
7grizzly
That was the bloke :-)
w
waterfowl
Like shooting at a bullet with a bullet, amazing!
盈盈一笑间
听说如果空袭,或者核战,DC.和纽约会是世界上最安全的地方,因为美国是空中拦截的重点保护对象?
盈盈一笑间
据说,DC的地铁都是防核弹设计的。
永远老李
美国曾经设想过星球大战计划,可以从太空保护整个美国。由于苏联崩溃,这计划用不着了

美国的超大城市肯定是重中之重。

永远老李
地下是很理想的防核冲击波,高温和核污染的地方
盈盈一笑间
因为在纽约,总感觉瑟瑟发抖。如果真发生战争,还是往中部玉米地跑,比较安全吧?
永远老李
淡定。在美国发生大规模战争的可能性甚微。美国每年无法数记的军费不是闹着玩的

在美国,死于战争的可能远远低于死于美国人自己的枪械的可能。