America: A Town Square Democracy

r
renqiulan
楼主 (文学峸)

Two historic democracies debuted in the late 18th century. One was terrible, the other terrific. *

The French Revolutionaries decapitated democracy with their guillotine during the Reign of Terror, thus giving Napoleon an opening to replace the short-lived republic with a monarchy. Emperor Napoleon, like his imperial predecessors, ruled from the high castle and looked down on his subjects.

On the other hand, America's first president George Washington governed---not ruled--- from the street-level town square, figuratively speaking. He had to work with Congress which held the power of the purse. Likewise for his successors.

Power shared is power limited. Everyone has to play the check-and-balance game. Frankly, this isn't a very efficient system. Still, it is effective enough to keep our unique republic going and growing.

In short, America is a town square democracy. It has stood the test of time. If history is any guide, this town square democracy will go on riding out future storms, one way or another.


Author: renqiulan

* Terrific but far from perfect, our democracy is always a work in progress. 

 


盈盈一笑间
沙发。巧了,我正好在线。秋兰,晚上好。:))
盈盈一笑间
Power shared is power limited. Good point.
盈盈一笑间
We need town square democracy.
卫宁
sometimes history repeats itself in somewhere.
r
renqiulan
无巧不成话。感谢盈盈!
r
renqiulan
It is common sense here. Elsewhere? Not so much.
r
renqiulan
We're living in a town square democracy, however
r
renqiulan
imperfect it is.
r
renqiulan
Point taken. Thank you, 卫宁! Would you be kind enough to
r
renqiulan
elaborate on the context for a start?
盈盈一笑间
Bipartisanship between GOP and the Democratic Party is
盈盈一笑间
prominent feature of the American political system,
盈盈一笑间
which lead to political deadlock and challenges in achieving
盈盈一笑间
consensus. This reflects the diversity in the states.
盈盈一笑间
There are still authoritarian dictatorships in the world
r
renqiulan
The democratic process is quite messy. So many conflicting
r
renqiulan
interests are involved. Everyone fights to bring bacon home.
r
renqiulan
So many hands want to be greased. At the end of the day,
r
renqiulan
though, by hook or by crook, we manage to
r
renqiulan
muddle through. Bottom line, a successful democracy
r
renqiulan
lets everyone live to fight another day.
卫宁
Last century same thing happened in China , Yuan Shikai
卫宁
replaced the short-lived republic with a monarchy shortly.
r
renqiulan
We can only do so much. Just make sure that
r
renqiulan
we won't get blindsided again.
盈盈一笑间
公元2023年之二次袁?:)
r
renqiulan
True. Thank you again!
卫宁
此二元一次方程有解乎?:))
盈盈一笑间
The tide of history cannot be turned.
r
renqiulan
Goodnight, guys!
盈盈一笑间
有解乎,无解乎?李中堂云,天在做,人在看。:)
盈盈一笑间
Indeed. The Democratic Party consists of a diverse range of
盈盈一笑间
perspectives and conflicting interests.
盈盈一笑间
和秋兰聊天,能学到好多地道的美语表达。谢谢你!比如:
盈盈一笑间
Everyone fights to bring bacon home.
盈盈一笑间
So many hands want to be greased.
盈盈一笑间
by hook or by crook, we manage to muddle through.
盈盈一笑间
Goodnight. :))
C
CBA7
Nice share, 秋兰!
C
CBA7
Is town hall meeting related with town square democracy? :)
唐宋韵
秋兰好。Thanks for sharing. I'm a little concerned about
唐宋韵
a slow metamorphosis of the town square itself...
r
renqiulan
盈盈周日早安!哪里呢?平常心,平常语;游观世,坐论世,如此而已。
r
renqiulan
I would say, political leverages make things happen---
r
renqiulan
good or bad. Whoever has the mandate also has the final say.
r
renqiulan
My reading of history is that ingenuity makes history.
r
renqiulan
I don't know about the "nice" part. I only know the " share"
r
renqiulan
part. That’s good enough for me. 谢谢小西,周日早安!
r
renqiulan
Indeed, town hall meetings are town square...
r
renqiulan
democracy in action. Of course, social media is the ultimate
r
renqiulan
town hall. At least, that's the case in this part of
r
renqiulan
the world. Words mean something here.
r
renqiulan
唐宋韵周日早安!I didn't quite catch your point. My apologies!
r
renqiulan
Perhaps, you might want to put "metamorphosis" in a context.
r
renqiulan
Then let's take it from there. Many thanks!
碼農學寫字
Couldn’t agree more “let everyone live to fight another day”
r
renqiulan
Thank you, 碼農學寫字! We have a living Constitution, which means
r
renqiulan
we have to guard against regression all the time.
碼農學寫字
Foe better or worse,any form of democracy is still democracy
唐宋韵
Sorry 没有说清楚。我是说我感到美国民主的土壤在变化,因为人口构成、社会思潮、持久和平等因素导致的逐渐变化。
r
renqiulan
Democracy in name or in substance? That's the question.
碼農學寫字
Well, I beg to differ. I grew up in the one that you may
碼農學寫字
Call Democracy in name, however many tiny steps put Taiwan
碼農學寫字
Where she is today.
r
renqiulan
I'd call it democratic evolution. Thanks for your feedback.
r
renqiulan
诚然如此。多族裔、多元文化正在考验美国民主社会的融和力。
C
CBA7
“social media is the ultimate town hall”, so true!
C
CBA7
秋兰真是谦谦君子啊。Thank you for the nice share and nice answers!
C
CBA7
同感,和盈盈一起同谢秋兰!
天玉之
Power shared is power limited. Everyone has to play the