大家帮忙看一下这个说法对吗?

沉默是嘛!
楼主 (文学峸)

今天手机的google页面推了一篇有关Backdoor Roth IRA 的文章,其中有下面这么一段话,说每年需要一个新的Roth IRA account.  我问了ChatGPT,又说不需要。是我对下面的话理解有误吗?  谢谢。

https://www.kiplinger.com/retirement/how-a-backdoor-roth-ira-works-and-drawbacks

The tax-free accumulation is the obvious attraction. But it comes with a relatively high administrative burden: Each year’s contribution has to be created as a separate Roth IRA account, meaning that if you make contributions for the next 20 years, you’ll be juggling 20 separate Roth IRA accounts.

仟仟
不对。不需要新的Roth account,只要把钱transfer进已有的account就行。都已经做了很多年了。
s
start2020
不知道是不是对的,我的税前IRA都是401 rollover的,所以又开了个税后IRA为后门传递。
s
start2020
还有个给后门开的RothIRA,一般报完税理清后,就把后门Roth IRA的钱再转进ROTH
沉默是嘛!
谢谢,ChatGPT也是像你这样说的。孩子已经有Roth IRA account. 我的理解只需再开个TIRA 就应该可

以做Backdoor Roth IRA了。以后不需要再开。

You can perform a Backdoor Roth IRA by transferring non-deductible contributions from a Traditional IRA to an existing Roth IRA. It doesn't have to be a new Roth IRA. The process involves making a non-deductible contribution to a Traditional IRA and then converting that amount to a Roth IRA.

E
EtoW2014
你这种情况,conver to Roth 是不是需要prorate?
仟仟
需要开一个传统IRA账户,把钱先存进传统账户里,然后transfer到Roth账户。传统账户留着以后用,不要关
江水草
你这样好像不可以哦,前几天刚讨论过,如有401 rollover IRA 需转去现在的公司,不然需要pro rata
仟仟
traditional IRA有钱的做后门Roth,需要prorate,很麻烦还不划算
F
Fudan2purdue
不是必需的,但有的人讲究,万一跌了,还可以转回来,下次再转过去。要这样操作就需要分别的账号