HOA是废是留?纠结中…..

c
caren
楼主 (文学峸)

有几个房子在一个HOA community,我是HOA的president。最近在考虑是不是要把HOA解散了。

解散的理由:

1. 只收钱不办事,做的最重要的事就是割草。其他砍树、修路、修管道每次都吵的不可开交不了了之

2. 管理公司收20%总收入

3. 要大家报名参加board member很少人报名

4. 问过的所有住户都赞成废掉HOA。需要2/3赞成票废掉,所以票不是问题

不废掉的理由:

1. 没有develop的lot上的草就没人剪了

2. parking lot大家就随便停了

3. 对新盖房子的要求就没人审理了

4. 现在HOA资产要转给别人

斗争中。大家有何建议?谢谢

柠檬椰子汁
Parking Lot? Is this TH?

Does HOA own common area, empty lot etc?  You have to transfer those areas to someone otherwise you can't dissolve the HOA. But I believe these things has to be done after dissolution vote was taken.  But has a plan first. 

c
caren
是。有16个visitor parking。前几天就有人在每个车上贴warning。所有人都给我发message或打电话

问咋回事。要single family话早给他废掉了

 

 

c
caren
HOA does not own all common areas; it owns two private roads
柠檬椰子汁
There is no way to you do without HOA

So TH community all parking are on a common lot, correct?  every family has designated parking space.  How are you subdivide the designated parking lot to individual homes?  

TH has to have HOA. 

c
caren
这是要保留Hoa的原因之一
冬前
没有HOA就像一个国家没有政府。当然,作为一员是一个吃力不讨好的志愿者,不过这影响每一家,人人都应付出
柠檬椰子汁
Worse than bad government is No government

Let them vote.  Have a full debate and exit plan, listing what will be missing.  If they still vote to terminate, so be it.   There will be weed, fading paint, broken asphalt, parking disputes, no snow removal, etc etc.  If they can't work with HOA in place, they can't work with neighbor without HOA. 

This is how Brexit happened.  David Cameron keep getting pressure from his party and he knows Brexit is a horrible idea, but his plan was to have a vote, and the vote would be not to leave EU, and he'd have some mandate to say "see vote happened and you'll have to let me work with EU."

Democracy fails sometimes.  Not all are leader's fault, sometimes it's the people. 

山里人家168
我们有个独立屋房主们联合起来解雇了HOA,没事。但康斗,城市屋还是有HOA比较好。
c
caren
是。除我以外每个HOA member都想quit。现在parking有问题才说服两个人留下
c
caren
说得至情至理!
落花起作回风舞
赞柠檬!说得太精辟了!
k
keeplooking
NO HOA. Good for you.
l
ljty1
读完最后一句话我就差站起来给柠檬鼓掌了!
k
kitfrommars
同意
安红豆
如果没有HOA,那你讲的砍树、修路、修管道都没人管了?City也不负责的话时间久了一定产生问题。

听起来你们小区是有些公共部分包括路面树木都是你们自己负责,不是City的责任,那以后路面破损了没人管不是更头疼?

c
caren
管道找过city,不管。每次都是我自己花钱修。其他住户也不分担
j
julie116
解散了管理公司依然在?
c
caren
管理公司是HOA雇的。管很多HoA,所以仍然还在