女儿被砸破头的妈妈,看这里

w
wenjun0126
楼主 (北美微论坛)
本帖最后由 wenjun0126 于 2018-5-11 22:15 编辑


更新
看到那位妈妈说,学校认定此次是accident,并非incident,从而推卸责任。此次保障权益的纠责重点不是(1)老师为什么没有预见可能的后果保护好孩子,也不是(2)找到对方孩子及家长要求赔偿 ,更不是(3)要求学校/daycare对此次事件进行经济赔偿(医药费、误工费等等) ,而是 (1)学校/daycare没有按照规定file report,(2)学校/daycare 侵犯了家长的知情权,(3)学校/daycare可能存在师生比例不合格等管理上的问题。


因为那位妈妈没有说孩子的年龄,也没有介绍孩子是在daycare还是public elementary school,姑且暫认是在daycare的五岁左右小朋友。如果是上小学,下面的第一条仍然适用但条款名称不同。


如果学校咬死accident免责(学校无需赔偿学生及家长损失),一下几点可以作为切入:
            1. The person in charge of a school (principal) shall provide a child's parent with information concerning incidents pertaining to the child. Logged entries shall include the name and date of birth of the child, the place, date and time of the accident or injury, names and positions of staff and other adults present, a brief statement as to how the accident or injury occurred, emergency treatment obtained, if any, and parental notification made or attempted.(§43.21.d) In New York State, the school is mandatory to file the Incident Report for Child Day Care form when the incident occurs.


          学校方并没有提供任何信息或进行说明, 已经违反了NY Child Care regulations。因此家长可以联系Office of Children and Family Services, Division of Child Care Services, 进行投诉。(https://ocfs.ny.gov/main/childcare/safety.asp,电话800-732-5207)。如在NYC,可电话311联系Department of Health。


           2. When the injuries happened, what was the teacher-student ratio on the playground? The school might not have enough qualified staff members on hand to supervise and monitor children and their activities, and that might leave children vulnerable to a wide range of accident injuries such as getting injured by other children. 这里不去纠事件的性质(对方孩子是不是故意的,有没有前科)或严重程度(出多少血),而是质疑学校的师生比是否在规定范围之内( 3y-5y, 1:20 in the classroom for academic activities; for other activities: 3y-4y, 1:10; 4y-5y, 1:12; 5y-6y, 1:25, NY州规定)。


家长可以要求office of Children and Family Services 或Department of Health 介入,从以上两点出发,审查幼儿园的执照资格。

最后再多嘴一句,此类事件中不要也不能追问对方学生的信息,也不可以通过其他途径联系对方家长。经济赔偿自己不要主动提,要占据道德的制高点,从规章制度和资格审查上入手。
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------《女儿在学校被同学用石头砸破头,应该怎么和学校交涉》的妈妈,希望这个回答能帮到您。

我觉得这个答案可能能帮助(以后帮助)一些对这方面需要帮助的家长,就单独开了帖子。




1.您应当马上联系校长。 明天给学校打电话,要求直接跟校长对话。(回帖中好多人建议报警,很可惜警察是不会受理学校发生的incident的。也不能查找是哪个学生扔的石块或找人家家长,只能纠校方的责任)
2. 保留照片证据,拍多角度孩子伤口,整体状态,认真记录孩子从今天开始的情绪、心理、生理反应 (如是否情绪低落、抵触学校,害怕看到血、晚上睡觉是否会惊醒等等)。
3.下面的话你可以直接复述给校长:
As promoted by the NYDoE and required by the New York State’s Dignity for All Students Act,  schools should promote safe learning environments to students so they can pursue academic excellence and social and emotional growth. However, what happened to my daughter yesterday made us doubt whether this school could provide safety during her days at school.  I was told by the nurse that there was a tinny wound on my daughter's forehead after I arrived. I did not receive any information about what happened or where did it happen. My daughter's clothes had already been changed, and she was having a bandage on the wound by that time. I was shocked when I saw the blood on her shirt and the actual size of the wound when we got home (如果是面谈,此处上照片,如果孩子有反常的心理、生理、情绪表现,进行描述)。


After this incident, I would like to discuss with you about several things. First, as required by the Safe Schools Against Violence in Education (SAVE) Act, all schools need to file Violent and Disruptive Incident Reports (VADIRs). In New York City, schools first file an incident report within 24 hours of its occurrence. I believe that as the parent, I have the right to receive an incident report as well to know what happened to my daughter. Since I have not received one, I am wondering whether the school has filed it to the SSEC? Also, violent and disruptive incidents reports must be maintained at the school until my daughter or the other person involved in the incident reaches the age of 27  and must be made available for review upon request by SED and/or auditors. So I am wondering whether the school is keeping the report as it supposes to be?


The second question is about the school's safety plan. Do we have an emergency response team or a post-incident response team? What is the process after incidents, and how can we make sure such incident will not happen to my daughter or any other student again? I encourage you to speak with the involved teacher and have a further investigation about the incident.


I believe you understand how sorrowful I was last night, and how hard I want my daughter to enjoy her school life within a safe environment. At this point, I would like to keep working with the school about the incident, and I would also like to reserve my rights to contact the DoE and SSEC, as well as to take suitable legal actions.


祝孩子早日康复不留疤!



d
dlxq2014
2 楼
楼主好厉害
x
xxx勃便便
3 楼
LZ太给力了!
活在OC的nancy
4 楼
顶上去!让更多父母看到!
j
jlll.ily
5 楼
赞啊
J
JO0703
6 楼
这个必须收藏,学习了谢谢楼主
多謝卉顧
7 楼
顶上去!!这样的事情一定不能姑息!!
V
Vivi0919
8 楼
赞!这个必须马克,以备不时之需
怕光的海芋
9 楼
必须马克
j
jilljill2
10 楼
楼主太棒了!帮顶!
c
christinalu
11 楼
赞一个
B
Belindaaaaaa
12 楼
楼主太赞了
用户acav1d91xe
13 楼
赞一个 好及时
S
Space789
14 楼
强悍的楼主
M
Missophia
15 楼
收藏
M
MissQi
16 楼
这个真的棒!
r
rainbowbow
17 楼
厉害顶上去
多小满
18 楼
赞!希望那个小女生不要留疤啊,那件衣服上的血迹真的叫人很心疼
健忘的小绵羊
19 楼
顶顶顶,这个好赞!
大牙cici
20 楼
upup 楼主太好了
橘子里的尼古丁
21 楼
这个帖子好,顶上去
淑Yu
22 楼
马住,希望以后不需要用到,希望所有的孩子都能健健康康快快乐乐
g
gracie567
23 楼
收藏收藏
猪大侠
24 楼
希望她看到呀,真的要找学校!
匿名
25 楼
帮顶!!
蛋花儿
26 楼
顶顶顶,好帖子!楼主好人!
v
vicky美眉
27 楼
用上了,我儿子和几个男同学今天在学校被大点的学生打了一拳
加州小樱桃
28 楼
帮顶
小松老师
29 楼
顶! lz好样的
小桃子Tina
30 楼
lz威武!
s
shallbytwo
31 楼
这个感觉是板上2年间最有用的帖子
煎饼果子_
32 楼
厉害!学习了
姜饼人er
33 楼
顶上去
水晶小莹
34 楼

好多泡lisa
35 楼
赞,马克一下
T
Tomo
36 楼
楼主好棒!!
糖糖糖eva
37 楼
厉害了 顶上去
S
Stephanie225
38 楼
赞楼主
大宝宝宝宝宝宝
39 楼
真棒!
s
sara88
40 楼
马可
X
XTJX
41 楼
mark了
w
waffle7
42 楼
楼主真好
李小饱Mini
43 楼
一定要顶上去 让更多的父母看到 楼主赞
a
alisa1103
44 楼
楼主真有耐心 这才是论坛真正的意义 互相帮助
s
shi1988
45 楼
楼主好强大 论坛是娘家人
匿名
46 楼
楼主棒棒的。应该去学律师。
r
raye
47 楼
LZ棒棒哒!!!
哈哈88哈哈
48 楼
赞楼主,好心人,热心肠,
匿名
49 楼
lz好棒
贝卡卡卡
50 楼
厉害
C
Cc_Phoebe
51 楼
顶上去 好棒!
大脸君的友家
52 楼
楼主大好人!!!
流景残梦
53 楼
顶上去!
P
PHOENIXTX
54 楼
楼主给力 点赞
莫老蜀黍
55 楼
顶上去.....加精华
王小莉
56 楼
顶上去
曦雨89
57 楼
厉害
曦雨89
58 楼
赞楼主 我也要学起来
芹茗子
59 楼
顶楼主
E
Elim_D
60 楼
楼主好强
菲利亚
61 楼
赞!这是干货
L
Lynn1515
62 楼
Lz太赞了,觉得可以加精了!
r
rosemarygtian
63 楼
这个真的好棒 希望小朋友可以健康安全快乐的成长
小点
64 楼
楼主太棒了
匿名
65 楼
厉害厉害
C
Ch12345
66 楼
好棒!!!
寻找喃喃小崽子
67 楼
楼主威武
方平
68 楼

怪兽投食官
69 楼
给楼主点赞
l
liliafeng76
70 楼
好棒!!
橘子小美
71 楼
楼主好厉害
我还是个宝宝33
72 楼

记忆的美好
73 楼
楼主太厉害,论坛就需要你这样的人。
甜蜜琳
74 楼
满分!同祝不留疤痕。
c
chloekkbb
75 楼
讚 厲害
S
Sara_Tse
76 楼
讚LZ!頂上去
Z
Zebra。
77 楼
楼主太厉害了!这种时候我们中国人互相帮助的美德就体现了
c
catlover
78 楼
楼主好棒!!!希望所有的孩子都能健康快乐长大
J
JudyChan
79 楼
Up up置顶
w
wuyunshen1996
80 楼
虽然我没有孩子 还是Mark 给楼主点赞 66666
小仙女Esther
81 楼
希望那位妈妈可以看到
匿名
82 楼
楼主好负责好有责任心! 感觉又看到了这个论坛积极的一面
P
Phoebeving
83 楼
楼主赞一万遍
匿名
84 楼
而且必须找律师!!!!去医院检查,律师会有一些列程序和相熟的医院教你怎么做!
优雅的Olivia
85 楼
厉害!我觉得有必要的话也需要带孩子去医院看看,再把证明拿给学校看
A
Axxxk
86 楼
流弊!顶!!
k
kennyllm
87 楼
有用的信息。谢谢热心人
再一秒_
88 楼
谢谢楼主!!帮顶
k
keane007
89 楼
楼主好人
M
Maggie0621
90 楼
收藏了
E
Elena咻咻
91 楼
楼主牛!人真好.赞一个
糖糖L
92 楼

舍不得睡
93 楼
好贴,顶一个
皮蛋瘦肉粥
94 楼
帮你顶上去,希望那位妈妈能看到!这个一定要维权,为了自己的孩子也为了别人孩子以后的安全
H
Hurricane根
95 楼

H
Hurricane根
96 楼
顶顶顶
H
Hurricane根
97 楼
再顶再顶再顶
J
Jessica123456
98 楼
谢谢楼主,已收藏
C
C_4cat
99 楼
我说未央
100 楼
楼主厉害