问了AI一个小问题,决定以后回国只飞国航,远离美联航

风轻雨
楼主 (北美华人网)
现在回国直飞航班不多。经常飞的航司只有国航和美联航。
刚才问了AI一个小问题,决定以后回国只飞国航,远离美联航。
这个问题是:What issues did United Airlines face in the past year?
同样也问了:What issues did Air China face in the past year?
关于美联航, AI 的回答如下:
In the past year, United Airlines has faced a range of challenges, including operational issues at Newark Liberty International Airport, labor disagreements, and incidents involving their aircraft. These issues have led to flight delays, cancellations, and increased scrutiny of the airline's safety procedures. 
关于国航,AI的回答是:
In the past year (roughly mid-2024 to mid-2025), Air China faced several challenges, primarily related to financial performance and a difficult market environment. 
Key issues Air China has faced include: Financial Losses: Despite efforts to improve operational efficiency and reduce losses compared to the previous year, the company continued to project and report net losses. While Air China's net loss attributable to shareholders improved significantly from 2023, the full-year operations in 2024 were still loss-making, indicating a rough final quarter. Intense Competition and Market Uncertainty: Air China cited increased domestic competition and volatility in international markets as contributing factors to their operational losses. China's "Big Three" airlines, including Air China, warned that domestic competition and supply chain pressures prolonged their losses in 2024. Slow International Travel Recovery: The slower-than-expected rebound in international travel, especially on traditionally advantageous North American routes, impacted Air China's profitability. Despite overall growth in international traffic, the recovery lagged behind pre-pandemic levels.
风轻雨
可以看出,国航的挑战是亏损,是竞争,是市场。
美联航的挑战是飞机安全问题,人员短缺,和空港安全问题。
风轻雨
美联航的incidents, 都是人命关天的
Key points about these incidents: Engine fires: A United flight experienced an engine fire during takeoff, causing an evacuation. The fire was reportedly attributed to a rabbit striking the engine.  Wheel falling off: In another incident, a United plane lost a wheel during takeoff, damaging vehicles on the ground.  Missing panel: A plane was found to be missing a panel after landing, prompting an investigation.  Potential implications: Increased scrutiny: These incidents are likely to draw increased attention from aviation authorities and the public to United Airlines' safety practices.  Investigations: The airline is likely to conduct thorough investigations into the causes of each incident to prevent similar occurrences in the future.  Passenger concerns: These incidents may raise concerns among passengers about the safety of flying with United Airlines. 
w
wudadan
回复 1楼 风轻雨 的帖子
坐过的所有航空公司的飞机里头 UA和AA的leg room是最小的
b
bbalyssa
我也是有其他航司就不选联航 真是要啥没啥
s
shanggj
风轻雨 发表于 2025-06-25 14:00
美联航的incidents, 都是人命关天的
Key points about these incidents: Engine fires: A United flight experienced an engine fire during takeoff, causing an evacuation. The fire was reportedly attributed to a rabbit striking the engine.  Wheel falling off: In another incident, a United plane lost a wheel during takeoff, damaging vehicles on the ground.  Missing panel: A plane was found to be missing a panel after landing, prompting an investigation.  Potential implications: Increased scrutiny: These incidents are likely to draw increased attention from aviation authorities and the public to United Airlines' safety practices.  Investigations: The airline is likely to conduct thorough investigations into the causes of each incident to prevent similar occurrences in the future.  Passenger concerns: These incidents may raise concerns among passengers about the safety of flying with United Airlines. 

刚问了 chatgpt 一样得问题, 和你得到得答案差不多, 然后我问 你推荐我做哪个公司得, 它说 united
风轻雨
shanggj 发表于 2025-06-25 14:22
刚问了 chatgpt 一样得问题, 和你得到得答案差不多, 然后我问 你推荐我做哪个公司得, 它说 united

ChatGPT是美联航的粉丝?
x
xdsqc
shanggj 发表于 2025-06-25 14:22
刚问了 chatgpt 一样得问题, 和你得到得答案差不多, 然后我问 你推荐我做哪个公司得, 它说 united

有没有追问WHY?
风轻雨
国航样样好,有一点不如美联航,
国航的票,在美国机场走不了TSA Pre快捷安检通道。
另外,国航座位前边电视屏幕的按键经常有小问题。
金生水起
wudadan 发表于 2025-06-25 14:03
回复 1楼 风轻雨 的帖子
坐过的所有航空公司的飞机里头 UA和AA的leg room是最小的

一定没有坐过纽约直飞北京的国航航班,那个leg room小到我不到100斤的都坐不下来,还没有屏幕没有任何充电孔,座椅超级破,供餐只有两顿,吃不饱。
y
yanhren
仔细看了一下是Air China operated by United airlines chatgpt问了一下,原来如此:
Air China 是这趟航班的“营销航空公司”(Marketing Carrier) → 你可能在国航官网、OTA(携程/Expedia)上看到这趟航班是“国航”的。 Operated by United Airlines 是指“实际承运人是美联航” → 飞机、机组、服务都是美联航的,乘客会在登机口看到美联航的LOGO和人员。 🧭 为什么会这样? 这叫代码共享航班(Code Share Flight),常见于航空联盟(如国航和美联航都属于“星空联盟 Star Alliance”),主要是为了: 航线覆盖更广(互补航线网络) 增加航班选择 共享常旅客积分
w
wueda
简单 发表于 2025-06-25 16:34
回复 2楼 风轻雨 的帖子
难道不是要比较同样路线的美国航班和国航的事故率,晚点率么?这些有得没的观点有p用?拿事实出来说话!

美联航最近一年那些掉轮子,掉机舱门,空中急降几千英尺的事故,国航没有吧
s
syzheng
UA 别的不说,感觉飞行员素质不错,每次降落都还挺平稳的
简单
回复 32楼 wueda 的帖子
没有就拿数据说话呀!每个坐飞机的人的需求都不一样。有人愿意冒很微小的risk去避开晚点,他可能就不做国航,楼主这种claim跟傻子似的。
g
goodluckall
回复 18楼 meraviglia 的帖子
请问这么做的理由是出于安全考虑吗?