对于national guards 的控制权问题说白了也是 states rights vs federal rights 之间的争斗， national guards by design 应该是给州长用的 国民警卫队的roots 是 colonial militias， 性质上属于 local defense force, 是隶属于州的，这是它存在和设计的初衷
When Can a President Take Control of the National Guard? A president can federalize the National Guard (i.e., take leadership from a governor) under the following circumstances: 1. Insurrection or Domestic Violence (Insurrection Act): • The president may federalize the National Guard if a state cannot or will not maintain order, enforce federal law, or protect constitutional rights, and the situation rises to the level of insurrection, rebellion, or domestic violence. • Examples: • To suppress an insurrection against federal or state authority (10 U.S.C. § 251). • When a state’s refusal or inability to enforce federal law obstructs its execution (10 U.S.C. § 252). • To protect civil rights when a state fails to do so (10 U.S.C. § 253). • Process: The president must issue a proclamation ordering insurgents to disperse before deploying federalized forces (10 U.S.C. § 254). However, this can be bypassed in urgent cases. 2. National Emergency or War: • Under Title 10, the president can federalize the National Guard during a declared national emergency, war, or other significant threats to national security (e.g., 10 U.S.C. § 12302 for partial mobilization). • Examples: Deployments for World War II, the Iraq War, or post-9/11 operations. 3. Enforcement of Federal Law: • If a governor refuses to enforce federal law or court orders (e.g., desegregation), the president can federalize the Guard to ensure compliance. • Historical example: In 1957, President Eisenhower federalized the Arkansas National Guard to enforce school desegregation in Little Rock after Governor Orval Faubus resisted. 4. Request or Consent of the Governor: • A governor may voluntarily request federal assistance, allowing the president to federalize the Guard for missions like disaster response or border security. • Example: Hurricane Katrina (2005), where the Louisiana National Guard was partially federalized to support relief efforts. 5. Other Statutory Authorities: • The president can federalize the Guard for specific missions under laws like the Stafford Act (for disaster relief) or homeland security operations, often in coordination with governors. • Example: Federalizing Guard units for COVID-19 response or border security missions under federal funding. 看得懂英文吗？ 满嘴造谣的五毛！
对于national guards 的控制权问题说白了也是 states rights vs federal rights 之间的争斗， national guards by design 应该是给州长用的 国民警卫队的roots 是 colonial militias， 性质上属于 local defense force, 是隶属于州的，这是它存在和设计的初衷 teabucket 发表于 2025-06-09 13:25
Walker1921 发表于 2025-06-09 13:36 When Can a President Take Control of the National Guard? A president can federalize the National Guard (i.e., take leadership from a governor) under the following circumstances: 1. Insurrection or Domestic Violence (Insurrection Act): • The president may federalize the National Guard if a state cannot or will not maintain order, enforce federal law, or protect constitutional rights, and the situation rises to the level of insurrection, rebellion, or domestic violence. • Examples: • To suppress an insurrection against federal or state authority (10 U.S.C. § 251). • When a state’s refusal or inability to enforce federal law obstructs its execution (10 U.S.C. § 252). • To protect civil rights when a state fails to do so (10 U.S.C. § 253). • Process: The president must issue a proclamation ordering insurgents to disperse before deploying federalized forces (10 U.S.C. § 254). However, this can be bypassed in urgent cases. 2. National Emergency or War: • Under Title 10, the president can federalize the National Guard during a declared national emergency, war, or other significant threats to national security (e.g., 10 U.S.C. § 12302 for partial mobilization). • Examples: Deployments for World War II, the Iraq War, or post-9/11 operations. 3. Enforcement of Federal Law: • If a governor refuses to enforce federal law or court orders (e.g., desegregation), the president can federalize the Guard to ensure compliance. • Historical example: In 1957, President Eisenhower federalized the Arkansas National Guard to enforce school desegregation in Little Rock after Governor Orval Faubus resisted. 4. Request or Consent of the Governor: • A governor may voluntarily request federal assistance, allowing the president to federalize the Guard for missions like disaster response or border security. • Example: Hurricane Katrina (2005), where the Louisiana National Guard was partially federalized to support relief efforts. 5. Other Statutory Authorities: • The president can federalize the Guard for specific missions under laws like the Stafford Act (for disaster relief) or homeland security operations, often in coordination with governors. • Example: Federalizing Guard units for COVID-19 response or border security missions under federal funding. 看得懂英文吗？ 满嘴造谣的五毛！
马斯克 这几天
每天都在给川普的帖子 ”点赞”
马斯克 服软了感觉，
过几天有可能会 把 马斯克 再次 揽入怀里，向大家炫耀
跟东大谈 如果谈不拢 折腾美华呗
终极目标是当皇帝 具体路径不详，他朝令夕改，恐怕自己也不清楚
这周主要折腾纽森
给纽森涨粉啊
涨不了一点
如果把纽森抓起来真会给他涨粉。
黄油靠边站。涨不涨粉跟你们没半毛钱关系。
现在也涨了很多了，纽森大叔不畏强权捍卫自由的演讲，使他看起来更帅了。
莫名其妙，公共论坛还捂嘴，黄左这么霸道
民主党22个州长已经表态反川了
你个川粉才是无知吧，在州长反对下强行调动national guards 本来就会有 legal , political and constitutional issues 这都不懂。
国民警卫队设计上隶属于州政府，总统强行接管国民警卫队，只能用 Insurrections 造反叛乱这种借口。 你才在传播misinformation. 当national guards 被总统强行federalized 以后，是不可以用来执行 domestic law-enforcement, 只有那种极端情况比如 insurrection act 才可以辩一下。 你们川粉的思维是不是以为州长和总统是上下级关系？ 太幼稚了
啥！200个deal被风给刮跑了吗？
国民警卫队的roots 是 colonial militias， 性质上属于 local defense force, 是隶属于州的，这是它存在和设计的初衷
黄川粉当奴才当习惯了，在他们的世界里，任何人不是主子就是奴隶，不是你给我跪着就是我给你跪着，大家都站着是绝对不允许的。
When Can a President Take Control of the National Guard? A president can federalize the National Guard (i.e., take leadership from a governor) under the following circumstances: 1. Insurrection or Domestic Violence (Insurrection Act): • The president may federalize the National Guard if a state cannot or will not maintain order, enforce federal law, or protect constitutional rights, and the situation rises to the level of insurrection, rebellion, or domestic violence. • Examples: • To suppress an insurrection against federal or state authority (10 U.S.C. § 251). • When a state’s refusal or inability to enforce federal law obstructs its execution (10 U.S.C. § 252). • To protect civil rights when a state fails to do so (10 U.S.C. § 253). • Process: The president must issue a proclamation ordering insurgents to disperse before deploying federalized forces (10 U.S.C. § 254). However, this can be bypassed in urgent cases. 2. National Emergency or War: • Under Title 10, the president can federalize the National Guard during a declared national emergency, war, or other significant threats to national security (e.g., 10 U.S.C. § 12302 for partial mobilization). • Examples: Deployments for World War II, the Iraq War, or post-9/11 operations. 3. Enforcement of Federal Law: • If a governor refuses to enforce federal law or court orders (e.g., desegregation), the president can federalize the Guard to ensure compliance. • Historical example: In 1957, President Eisenhower federalized the Arkansas National Guard to enforce school desegregation in Little Rock after Governor Orval Faubus resisted. 4. Request or Consent of the Governor: • A governor may voluntarily request federal assistance, allowing the president to federalize the Guard for missions like disaster response or border security. • Example: Hurricane Katrina (2005), where the Louisiana National Guard was partially federalized to support relief efforts. 5. Other Statutory Authorities: • The president can federalize the Guard for specific missions under laws like the Stafford Act (for disaster relief) or homeland security operations, often in coordination with governors. • Example: Federalizing Guard units for COVID-19 response or border security missions under federal funding. 看得懂英文吗？ 满嘴造谣的五毛！
川粉的逻辑
你自己看得懂吗，这不就是我说的极端情况。 而且你貌似连国民警卫队的起源都不懂。 家教不行啊
是的，不怕不识货就怕货比货。我本来已经不想看到他了，这次再看到他一下觉得他的形象又高大起来了