马一龙发了一道海淀小学数学题

g
gzrk
楼主 (北美华人网)
w
whatever.
按照我小时候学的规则,这题是9
不知道现在啥规则
j
jiekodak
9
y
youyouzou

Elon会说 答案是 6/23,因为他会创新
E
Ericcheung17
以前看过,括号不规范,两种答案都行,现在已经没有这种出题方式了。
c
cecewang520
我看全网正确答案说是1
11111111
a
aegeanboat
美国这边教的是1。 严谨的数学教育是9。
f
firstautumn
得9的去重修一下吧!
o
oldbear1
aegeanboat 发表于 2025-04-28 22:29
美国这边教的是1。 严谨的数学教育是9。

严谨的话乘号是不能省略的。
f
foreverf
6÷2×3=9
渔非凡
2靠括号那么近是为了让人先算后面的?
m
mzntmlgb
这道题已经trend 到google搜索默认输入了,打6/ 就看到题目
m
mzntmlgb
gzrk 发表于 2025-04-28 22:05

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEngineers/comments/5icxyd/whats_the_actual_correct_answer_for_6212/?rdt=63061
d
dsgea
8年前就有人问过了 这个模仿马仿佛没上过网一样 https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEngineers/comments/5icxyd/whats_the_actual_correct_answer_for_6212/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button
v
virtue
我看是1。
k
kissingsherry
括号优先 然后从左到右
f
feicui
kissingsherry 发表于 2025-04-28 22:43
括号优先 然后从左到右

括号优先,但是2在括号外面,所以除法做完再做乘法
剔透玲珑
6 除以 2 再乘3, 不是9吗? 除号后面部分再加个括号才算出来1
f
foreverf
dsgea 发表于 2025-04-28 22:40
8年前就有人问过了 这个模仿马仿佛没上过网一样 https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEngineers/comments/5icxyd/whats_the_actual_correct_answer_for_6212/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

呃,所以马是嘲笑海淀不会出题?
混凝土举人
6除以2个3,答案是1。括号里优先级比乘除高一级,肯定先算,这没有异议。主要是2和括号,这里不能完全等同于乘号,应该视为比乘除高半级,优先算
小小雀雀
kissingsherry 发表于 2025-04-28 22:43
括号优先 然后从左到右

括号里面的优先。 括号外面的按照顺序先乘除后加减
M
MARCH13
1
t
tigerpi314
不是9吗?难道?
j
jingzhang2
出题不严谨。又没有变量字母,为啥运算符号省略掉?
e
esprit88
2后面没有x号,也可默认为方,那就是6/2的3次方,就是3/4
D
Daylight
不是1?看看有啥新花
x
xiaoxiaodada
9, 括号=3, r然后从左到右6/2*3
I
IronFlower
Google说是9😂
s
sffdffgh
完了 以前学的全忘了
e
esprit88
Deepseek脑子也快烧坏了

6/2(1+2) Okay, so I've come across this math problem: 6/2(1+2). At first glance, it seems straightforward, but I remember hearing that these kinds of problems can be tricky because of the order of operations. Let me try to work through it step by step. First, I need to recall the order of operations, often remembered by the acronym PEMDAS—Parentheses, Exponents, Multiplication and Division (from left to right), Addition and Subtraction (from left to right). Let's apply that here. The expression is 6 divided by 2 multiplied by (1+2). The parentheses should be addressed first. Inside the parentheses, 1 plus 2 equals 3. So now the expression simplifies to 6 divided by 2 multiplied by 3. Now, according to PEMDAS, after handling the parentheses, we do multiplication and division from left to right. So starting from the left: 6 divided by 2 is 3. Then, multiplying that result by 3 gives 9. That seems straightforward. But wait, I've heard some people argue that when there's a number directly next to parentheses, like 2(1+2), that multiplication should be done before division. If that were the case, then 2 multiplied by 3 equals 6, and then 6 divided by 6 equals 1. But isn't that contradicting the left-to-right rule for multiplication and division? Let me check some examples or official math rules to clarify. According to standard mathematical conventions, multiplication and division have the same priority and should be performed from left to right. So in 6/2×3, you do 6 divided by 2 first, which is 3, and then multiply by 3 to get 9. The absence of an explicit multiplication sign doesn't change the order; it's still considered multiplication and follows the same left-to-right rule. However, the confusion might arise because when a number is adjacent to parentheses, people might associate it more closely, thinking it's part of a single term. But strictly speaking, unless there's a fraction bar or additional parentheses indicating otherwise, the left-to-right rule applies. To test this, if the expression were written as 6/(2(1+2)), then the answer would indeed be 1, because the denominator would be 2 multiplied by 3, making the entire denominator 6, and 6 divided by 6 equals 1. But without those extra parentheses around the denominator, the original expression is 6 divided by 2, multiplied by 3. Another way to look at it is by using fractions. If we write it as 62×(1+2) 2
6 ​×(1+2), that's 62×3=3×3=9 2
6 ​×3=3×3=9. However, if it were 62(1+2) 2(1+2)
6 ​, then it would be 66=1 6
6 ​=1. The placement of parentheses changes the interpretation. So in the original problem, since there are no parentheses around the denominator, the correct answer should be 9. The key takeaway is that the order of operations must be strictly followed, and the presence of adjacent parentheses doesn't inherently prioritize that multiplication over division unless parentheses explicitly group them together. I think I've got it now. The answer is 9 based on standard order of operations. The confusion comes from how the expression is written and the assumption that adjacent numbers to parentheses take precedence, but according to PEMDAS, it's left-to-right for multiplication and division once parentheses and exponents are handled. The expression 6/2(1+2) can be solved using the standard order of operations (PEMDAS/BODMAS):
Step-by-Step Explanation: Parentheses/Brackets Solve the expression inside the parentheses first: (1+2)=3 (1+2)=3 Now the equation simplifies to: 6÷2×3 6÷2×3 Division and Multiplication (Left-to-Right) Division and multiplication have equal precedence, so resolve them from left to right. Divide 6 by 2: 6÷2=3 6÷2=3 Multiply the result by 3: 3×3=9 3×3=9 Final Answer: 9 9

Why the Confusion? Some interpret 2(1+2) as a single unit (denominator), assuming implicit multiplication takes priority. However, strict PEMDAS rules prioritize left-to-right order for division and multiplication unless parentheses explicitly group terms. Clarification: If written as 62(1+2) 2(1+2)
6 ​, the answer would be 1. Without extra parentheses, 6/2(1+2) resolves to 9. Key Takeaway: Always follow left-to-right order for operations of equal precedence, and use parentheses to avoid ambiguity.



6/2(1+2) = 3/4
The server is busy. Please try again later.
w
wonaiwangerxiao
渔非凡 发表于 2025-04-28 22:35
2靠括号那么近是为了让人先算后面的?

虽然我也是这么想这么算的、但是被你这么一说忽然就差点喷饭了…..
q
qgp
这么无聊的题目,全看规定和对规则的解读。太无聊了
v
vivian.
回复 31楼 esprit88 的帖子
哈哈哈烧疯了
t
taoyantaoyan1999
没看parody么,不是马一龙,马一龙怎么会发这种东西
p
phlin
回复 21楼 混凝土举人 的帖子
我贊成緊貼著括號的先算
括號看著就煩 先去掉再說
E
EvenOdd
gzrk 发表于 2025-04-28 22:05

= 6 over 2*3
= 1
z
zx2013
1. 括号和2之间省约了✖️所以先算
一切
9, 从来没学过省略✖️就要先算的规则, 啥时候开始的?
p
phlin
回复 36楼 phlin 的帖子
那年
春天晚上
鍵盤黏答答的
一個做題家
看到了省略乘號的括號
發覺 躲在 九 上面的左 括號 跟躲在玲上面的右括號
太難打了 為了接下來數學式的簡單化
決定 括號旁省略的乘號 先算
f
forger3
这是加拿大大选的一个梗,说加拿大是一群认为这个等于7的和认为等于1的在互相认为对方错了。
评论里应该有介绍怎么算等于7的
Z
Ziggyy
是马一龙恶搞号……不是马本人
P
Peacelife
9啊 1的话2(1+2)外面还得有个大括号才行
旗亭画壁
9
f
fannysunny
9
啥玩意
foreverf 发表于 2025-04-28 22:48
呃,所以马是嘲笑海淀不会出题?

这怎么可能是海淀出的题?笑死了
s
shanggj
dsgea 发表于 2025-04-28 22:40
8年前就有人问过了 这个模仿马仿佛没上过网一样 https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEngineers/comments/5icxyd/whats_the_actual_correct_answer_for_6212/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

是感觉有些年头了。
寻隐者不遇
我不记得小学四则运算可以省略乘号了,省略乘号是学了代数之后才比较make sense,四则运算省略乘号属于题出错了
宝宝宝宝宝
gzrk 发表于 2025-04-28 22:05

chatgpt 的答案是 9
a
autofill
怎么得出来的1? 我觉得是9啊。
J
JBJ17
虽然觉得是九,但没有乘号有些突兀。
f
feifeiduan
如果标题说这是一道海淀的数学题,明显正确答案是9啊。
全网说正确答案是1,那是美国的全网。按中国教育,中国人不可能得出1的答案。
y
ytxdz
firstautumn 发表于 2025-04-28 22:30
得9的去重修一下吧!

竟然有28个赞!这是华人论坛啊。 按严格数学,就是9.省略乘号在算术里确实有点奇怪,但能缺省的也只有乘号。 得1的是认为乘法比除法优先级高吗?
s
shanggj
ytxdz 发表于 2025-04-29 16:32
竟然有28个赞!这是华人论坛啊。 按严格数学,就是9.省略乘号在算术里确实有点奇怪,但能缺省的也只有乘号。 得1的是认为乘法比除法优先级高吗?

有人说 省略了乘号的 有高优先级。 一点道理没有。
f
feifeiduan
答案9。
中国的试题里经常这种让人一不小心就做错的题,如果在国内上过初中,看到这样的题就会立刻警戒,不会做错
贝贝妈2008
海淀区的学前班出这样的数学题?
看按不按照之前的规则啦,按照的话,就是9。要不然的话,随便吧。。6都不一定是6,有啥好算的,躺平吧。。
s
somuch
1
h
hellensiao
k
kittyblue
马一龙算个屁, 他的数学估计不如这个版上的平均值
o
oldbear1
ytxdz 发表于 2025-04-29 16:32
竟然有28个赞!这是华人论坛啊。 按严格数学,就是9.省略乘号在算术里确实有点奇怪,但能缺省的也只有乘号。 得1的是认为乘法比除法优先级高吗?

1/9a,你觉得是1/9 *a 还是1/(9a)?
y
ytxdz
oldbear1 发表于 2025-04-29 18:07
1/9a,你觉得是1/9 *a 还是1/(9a)?

这个是1/(9a).代数和算术不一样啊 算术一般不应该省略乘号,题目省了,还是题目出得不严谨了
o
oldbear1
ytxdz 发表于 2025-04-29 18:33
这个是1/(9a).代数和算术不一样啊 算术一般不应该省略乘号,题目省了,还是题目出得不严谨了

不是一般不省略,而是算术不可以省略,但是省略乘号出题人的思路就是代数式的整体思路。得出9的正确性肯定不比得出1高
f
fatfeet
AI gemini说答案是9 如果认为2(2+1)是并置,类似于分母的话,就是1.
y
yemao
按照我小时候学过的规则, 答案是 1.