Poll: 60% of Americans Says U.S. Does Not Need Any More H-1B Visa Workers https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/12/27/poll-60-of-americans-says-u-s-does-not-need-any-more-h-1b-visa-workers/ https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/world/americans-say-us-doesn-t-need-more-foreigners/ar-AA1wMLS4 The majority of likely American voters says the United States does not need any more foreign H-1B visa workers to fill white-collar jobs, a new poll finds. A Rasmussen Reports survey reveals that 6-in-10 Americans say the U.S. “already has enough talented people to train and recruit” for white-collar jobs when asked whether Congress should increase the inflow of foreign workers, primarily those arriving through the H-1B visa program.
Breitbart新闻的标题的确是你说的那个意思：60%的受访者认为不应该再有H1B了。 https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/12/27/poll-60-of-americans-says-u-s-does-not-need-any-more-h-1b-visa-workers/ 但是原始的Rasmussen Survey的问题是“Should Congress increase the number of foreign workers taking higher-skill U.S. jobs or does the country already have enough talented people to train and recruit for most of those jobs?” 似乎问的还是要不要增加H1B名额。 该问题下面还有一问“In terms of the effect on the overall quality of life in the United States, do you favor continuing this level of immigration-driven population growth, slowing down immigration-driven population growth or having no immigration-driven population growth at” 回答保持现状的占28%，认为应该减缓移民带来的人口增长的占44%，认为应该不要有移民带来的人口增长的占18%，不确定的占10%。 https://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/immigration_index/crosstabs_rasmussen_reports_immigration_index_novermber_25_2024
https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/12/27/poll-60-of-americans-says-u-s-does-not-need-any-more-h-1b-visa-workers/ https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/world/americans-say-us-doesn-t-need-more-foreigners/ar-AA1wMLS4
The majority of likely American voters says the United States does not need any more foreign H-1B visa workers to fill white-collar jobs, a new poll finds. A Rasmussen Reports survey reveals that 6-in-10 Americans say the U.S. “already has enough talented people to train and recruit” for white-collar jobs when asked whether Congress should increase the inflow of foreign workers, primarily those arriving through the H-1B visa program.
再读一下标题
H1B 都反对，更别想敞开绿卡大门了。而且绿卡向来按国籍分配，不太可能为烙印网开一面。
同时，因为H1B难拿而被abuse的L1签证也得重新审视了。
我也这么觉得。但是已经被烙印玩坏了，非法移民都赶不出去，已经进来的H1b更赶不走了
不可能的，X上一吵吵，给美国人科普了是老印在Abuse H1B，对烙印深恶痛绝，绝对不会取消国别Cap的
我也在疑惑我英文出了啥问题，any more….
Breitbart新闻的标题的确是你说的那个意思：60%的受访者认为不应该再有H1B了。 https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/12/27/poll-60-of-americans-says-u-s-does-not-need-any-more-h-1b-visa-workers/
但是原始的Rasmussen Survey的问题是“Should Congress increase the number of foreign workers taking higher-skill U.S. jobs or does the country already have enough talented people to train and recruit for most of those jobs?” 似乎问的还是要不要增加H1B名额。
该问题下面还有一问“In terms of the effect on the overall quality of life in the United States, do you favor continuing this level of immigration-driven population growth, slowing down immigration-driven population growth or having no immigration-driven population growth at” 回答保持现状的占28%，认为应该减缓移民带来的人口增长的占44%，认为应该不要有移民带来的人口增长的占18%，不确定的占10%。
https://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/immigration_index/crosstabs_rasmussen_reports_immigration_index_novermber_25_2024
关键要抵制印度的滥用。其实取消亲属移民和难民比取消H1B好。。。
H1-B abuse的根源到底在哪里？
还有工作外包的问题。但这个真难管，毕竟是资本社会，估计只有控制印度人做高管。
利益呀。故意的。出卖美国中产阶级的利益。
其实最主要的根源还是世界上有很多其他国家远远没有美国富。那么多人偷渡来美国也是类似的道理。H1B滥用和偷渡其实性质类似，只不过一个合法一个非法。
然后就是H1B规则漏洞太多，很容易被绕过。
当然，美国国内社会阶层分化严重，最底层的人（比如那些吸毒的）可能连最低薪的简单劳动都从事不了，可能也是老板有动力滥用H1B雇佣便宜外国人的原因之一，但应该不是最主要原因。
正确的做法我觉得应该仿效类似加拿大的技术移民， 每年自由控制名额就好了。 h1b 由公司负责，确实很容易 abuse.
首先要解决abuse的情况，然后解决外包的工作流失，再谈是不是需要增加
如果印度人手上有决定的权利，本地美国人/非印度的其他移民符合要求的高质量人才被雇佣的可能性，还不如那些空降的没有美国文凭的印度人
如果root cause不解决，大量的H1B也会被印度人abuse，反而不利于吸引真正的人才（印度人有不错的人才，但滥竽充数的太多）
现在是很多人认为H1B进来的人侵占了美国绿卡公民的工作机会，这类工作主要是中产阶层，取消亲属移民和难民有啥用？