求助:我该如何找老师谈话?

n
njchina
楼主 (北美华人网)
正在学美国历史的五年级娃回家问我:现在社会上还有没有slavery ?我说应该没有了吧。结果娃说老师说现在的中国还有slavery。

华人姐妹们,我该如何做?
谢谢!
I
Icelus
你可以直接找校长面谈了吧?
n
njchina
我是准备发个email给校长。想听听华人姐妹们的建议,想想如何措辞。谢谢
e
erazoryee99
回复 1楼 njchina 的帖子
用Google Gemini帮你起草一份抗议信供参考。你也用其他AI写一下再中和。
主题:Regarding False Information about Slavery in China Dear Principal [校长姓名], I am writing to express my concern about a statement made by my child's teacher regarding the existence of slavery in China. My child, who is currently in fifth grade, informed me that their teacher had asserted that slavery still exists in China today. I was deeply troubled by this statement, as it is factually incorrect and potentially harmful. Slavery was abolished in China in 1953, and there is no evidence to suggest that it is practiced anywhere in the country today. It is crucial that our children are taught accurate information about history and current events, and perpetuating such misconceptions can have serious consequences. I urge you to investigate this matter and take appropriate action to ensure that accurate information about slavery is being presented to students. It is essential that our educators are well-informed and provide students with a truthful understanding of the world around them. Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely, [你的名字]
e
erazoryee99
回复 3楼 njchina 的帖子
觉得https://claude.ai/ 回复的更好:
Subject: Concern about statement made in history class
Dear Principal [Name],
I am writing to express my concern about a statement made by one of the 5th grade teachers at your school regarding the existence of slavery in modern China. When my child came home from their history lesson today, they stated that the teacher told the class that slavery still exists in China currently. As you can imagine, making a claim like this about a major country is an extremely serious allegation. Slavery is a horrific violation of human rights that was constitutionally abolished in China in 1910 and made illegal throughout the 20th century. While forced labor regimes have occurred in China's past, there is no credible evidence that a system of slavery still operates and is accepted by the modern Chinese government and society. Speculating about ongoing state-sanctioned slavery in China is not only highly inflammatory, but it promotes an inaccurate understanding of the current situation there. I am concerned that presenting this as fact to impressionable young students could reinforce harmful stereotypes. I respectfully request that you look into this matter and ensure students are receiving historically accurate information about modern China from properly trained personnel. I would appreciate being updated on how this will be addressed. Thank you for your attention to this serious issue. I look forward to your response.
Sincerely,
[Your name]


Please note that you may need to modify this email template to fit your specific situation. For instance, you may need to include your child's name, grade level, and the teacher's name.
z
zokiya
我个人觉得应该先跟老师沟通下,然后看情况是否有必要再跟校长说。
p
paltry
第二封回复真好。
L
LimitedEdition
zokiya 发表于 2024-03-13 12:13
我个人觉得应该先跟老师沟通下,然后看情况是否有必要再跟校长说。

跟老师说没用 这老师明显对中国有偏见 直接找校长把事闹大了才行 让老师跟全班学生澄清自己说的是错的 中国现在没有奴隶制 给他点颜色 以后他也能收敛点
I
Icelus
zokiya 发表于 2024-03-13 12:13
我个人觉得应该先跟老师沟通下,然后看情况是否有必要再跟校长说。

能跟学生说出这种话的老师,完全没有沟通的必要。 这不是老师无知的问题,是深深的偏见和狭隘。
M
MUQIN_maternity
我支持先跟老师沟通一下,看看他的态度,然后再决定要不要跟校长说,或者如何跟校长说
b
bluesky_i
先跟老师沟通一下,这也太无知了
Y
YYFLy
你至少先问问娃老师具体是怎么说的吧,娃怎么得出结论是中国有slavery的,然后跟老师聊聊娃最后理解成这样了怎么教育比较好,一起商量下怎么跟娃清楚的解释这件事情。在做这一切的过程中,如果发现老师有严重的偏见,或者态度极差才involve校长吧。
W
WarmClock
孩子前几天回家跟我说,班上有个小朋友说中国的自来水里有屎。是真的吗?
我跟孩子讲,妈妈长这么大,去过几十个城市,没这事。 你去问问你的小伙伴怎么知道的,是他自己还是他爸妈去中国喝过屎水?
W
WarmClock
美国白人多的环境歧视挺多。 还有一次,孩子班上的小孩说,中国的东西质量都很差。
我告诉孩子这么回答: 1) 质量差还买,只能说明这个小朋友家的人蠢。
2)另外,美国市场上大部分产品是中国制造的,要是质量都差,为什么商场还进货? 你的小朋友家长为了便宜买中国产品,嫌差买高价的别的国家的产品啊。 没钱花高价,买了低价又抱怨,也说明他们脑子有问题。

A
ABC小阿呆
这种还是要弄清楚老师的态度
小红马甲
建议版主把这类帖子汇总一下长期置顶,帮助华人家长和孩子应对生活中各种歧视和偏见。