最近重温韩国世越号事件,典型的东亚高压威权体系和过度信任集体的mindset制造的巨大悲剧

d
doctor.evil
楼主 (北美华人网)
从船长到各级官员,都在发现自己决策错误后本能的去掩盖而不是去进行damage control。 像极了东亚家庭里犯了错的娃不敢承认错误,宁愿硬着头皮扯谎拖延最终后果的到来。
那些被困的学生老师和救援人员,哪怕发现船体严重倾斜,也愿意相信船长广播,指挥相信组织会有万全的计划,最后能井然有序的安全撤离。
但凡船里的人不听指挥,竞相逃命,四散奔逃,救援的不听指挥,一哄而上,最后的死的人都会少的多。



S
Sleepy3824
韩国好像尤其是这样。
KA 801 空难 The NTSB was critical of the flight crew's monitoring of the approach, and even more critical of why the first officer and flight engineer did not challenge the captain for his errors. Even before the accident, Korean Air's crew resource management program was already attempting to promote a free atmosphere between the flight crew, requiring the first officer and flight engineer to challenge the captain if they felt concerned.[1]: 59  The flight crew only began to challenge the captain six seconds before impact, though, when the first officer urged the captain to make a missed approach. 
Asiana 214 空难 Investigation of the Asiana Airlines accident in San Francisco last summer revealed that one of the co-pilots was afraid to warn his captain about the low-speed landing. He kept silent. The plane crashed short of the runway. Three people were killed and 181 others were injured. Asian’s Chief Executive Kim Soo-cheon later said that Koreans tend “toward a patriarchal culture and many pilots work and fly within the strict military order.”



c
chatchat
德州学校枪击案家长倒是不听指挥想冲进去救孩子,警察不是不让吗。
K
Kirin9000s
韩国已经拿到美国发的民主证了 怎么让你说的还不如北朝鲜呢
a
aiyamayayongle
从船长到各级官员,都在发现自己决策错误后本能的去掩盖而不是去进行damage control。 像极了东亚家庭里犯了错的娃不敢承认错误,宁愿硬着头皮扯谎拖延最终后果的到来。
那些被困的学生老师和救援人员,哪怕发现船体严重倾斜,也愿意相信船长广播,指挥相信组织会有万全的计划,最后能井然有序的安全撤离。
但凡船里的人不听指挥,竞相逃命,四散奔逃,救援的不听指挥,一哄而上,最后的死的人都会少的多。




doctor.evil 发表于 2024-02-12 18:19

结论无法验证,前面说的基本不错。