hoa 这罚款要要求免掉吗?

c
coinbase
楼主 (北美华人网)
事情是这样的,2022年9月 树上大白天隔三差五掉大树枝(下面第一个照片),我给hoa 发email 说 你们要不找人修一下树吧,万一砸到人,树下这条路走的人还挺多的,包括很多学生,怎么办,发了两次, hoa 都没采取任何措施, 我就自己简单trim 树了,因为家里有孩子,经常在这树下玩耍,害怕砸到他们, 2023年1月换了hoa,新的hoa 2023年7月发现我自己trim tree了,给了警告,意思是不能私自trim 树,也没说罚款,就说让我以后有trim 树的需求,联系hoa,不要自己单干,我之后再也没trim过 今天 hoa的人说这棵树因为我的trim,快死了,感觉就是扯淡,要把这棵树拔了,然后种新树,所有开销都让我自己出,大概1k 刀
我今天早上拍的照片在最下面 首先:树根本没死,还绿着呢,其次即使死了,都半年过去了,怎么证明是我trim导致的? 还有之前的hoa 不作为,没有及时trim 树,我才自己动手trim的, 新hoa 认旧hoa的帐吗?
我去hoa meeting argue 胜算几率大吗? 谁有经验
如果树枝砸到人,hoa 要负责吗? 还是owner 付全责?




chatgpt 帮我写的argue 信
Subject: Request for Reconsideration Regarding Tree Removal Cost Dear xxx, I hope this email finds you well. I am writing to address the concern raised about the tree near my house and the potential cost associated with its removal. As mentioned in my previous email, my primary motivation for trimming the tree was to ensure the safety of my family, neighbors, and pedestrians who frequently pass by. Given that two significant branches had already fallen last year, I felt a sense of urgency to mitigate any potential risks associated with the tree. I understand the importance of maintaining a visually appealing and safe environment within the community, which is why I took the initiative to trim the tree in the absence of any action from the HOA after expressing my concerns. It was not my intention to create any conflict but rather to contribute to the overall safety of our community. In the past six months since I stopped trimming the tree, I have closely monitored its condition. I am pleased to report that the tree continues to display a healthy appearance, with no signs of dying such as yellowing leaves. This observation aligns with my initial assessment that the tree was not negatively impacted by the pruning. I would like to emphasize the significant ecological and aesthetic benefits that this mature tree brings to our community. Large, established trees, like the one in question, play a crucial role in enhancing air quality, providing shade, and supporting local wildlife. Removing a tree of this size would disrupt the ecosystem it sustains and diminish the overall greenery and beauty of our neighborhood. Moreover, mature trees contribute to the overall value of our properties. They are known to increase property values and contribute positively to the overall ambiance of the neighborhood. Planting a new, small tree in place of the existing mature tree would require many years to reach a comparable size and provide similar benefits. Considering the current healthy state of the tree and the numerous advantages it brings to our community, I kindly request a reconsideration of the proposed cost for its removal. I believe that the tree''''s condition does not warrant such drastic measures, and I am more than willing to collaborate with the HOA to explore alternative solutions to address any concerns regarding the tree''''s maintenance. I appreciate your attention to this matter and your dedication to maintaining the well-being of our community. If necessary, I am open to discussing this further or providing additional information to support my request. Thank you for your understanding and cooperation. Best regards,
t
tbaobao
坚决不碰有 HOA的房子,HOA是无尽的烦恼之源。