有明白人给讲讲ftp和EDI 有什么区别么?

j
johndoe123
楼主 (北美华人网)
EDI传输数据比较贵,而且要customize? FTP 就是对方把数据下载到xml or excel我们手工upload到自己的系统里?还是ftp可以把数据传送到一些shared drive上让我们看?ftp就是多了一个手动步骤? EDI 就是直接把数据integrate到使用的系统里了?
a
aeo60189
既然你有这个疑问 不如哪个简单用什么了 。成本是在你掌握了知识后再考虑的
j
johndoe123
FTP 类似于Dropbox么?
j
johndoe123
Upup
w
wdong
不管什么场合都不要用ftp,因为协议不安全。EDI本身从名字上看并没有指定协议。但是从实际情况来说EDI这一套是独立于互联网发展起来的,而且特定于行业,一般应该只有比较大的企业用得起。对于不同的公司, EDI可能指的是某个特定的数据传输协议。
w
wqguy
EDI传输数据比较贵,而且要customize? FTP 就是对方把数据下载到xml or excel我们手工upload到自己的系统里?还是ftp可以把数据传送到一些shared drive上让我们看?ftp就是多了一个手动步骤? EDI 就是直接把数据integrate到使用的系统里了?
johndoe123 发表于 2022-12-03 16:04

EDI only defines a set of document formats for various business transactions. Some examples of business transactions include sales orders, shipments, and invoices. For example, an EDI document type 850 is for orders.
EDI does not define how an EDI document is transported from one partner to the other. Since EDI''s creation in the 1960s, transportation protocols for EDI documents have also been evolving. Currently, you can send EDI documents over FTP(SFTP), HTTPS, or any legacy transportation protocols as long as both business partners agree to it.
As for automation, there are many integration platforms available to automate EDI transactions no matter the transport protocols. You can also create your own program to pick up EDI documents (files) sent via FTP or HTTP, parse them and then do whatever you want with the content. But nowadays, it is more common to use an integration platform to automate EDI transactions.
d
dalianyin
edi 传输数据要有一定的format 有一定的data validation ftp是个text file就能传 binary 我不清楚
d
dalianyin
这俩都是application layer的 protocol 都是建立在tcp我想? 所以所谓的所谓的安全都是在application layer做一些data validation
C
ChristinaW
ftp transfers edi files.
j
johndoe123
FTP transfer file具体怎么操作呢?没有现成的软件用必须找开发人员customize?是想从外部的数据系统女直接传送一些文件到内部的系统里