前几天在reddit看到的一个回答，讲cs在文理学院和工学院的区别 https://www.reddit.com/r/cmu/comments/xmsnxa/would_love_to_see_cmu_cs_ver_of_this_stanford/ Full Disclosure] I am staff, not faculty. I think he's mixed up Computer Science (Process Science) and Software Engineering (practical application of Process Science). ' ---- When I attended undergrad (not CMU), the Computer Science department was housed in the College of Science (Economics, Chemistry, Mathematics, Physics, et cetera). This made sense because it was the mathematical study of theoretical computer science. Sadly they moved the Computer Science department to the College of Engineering and have tried to make it a vocational degree. There's nothing wrong with working in industry, and there's nothing wrong with wanting to specialize within a very large field. However, to prioritize application over theory defeats the study of any science. ' ---- It's up to the student studying any sort of theoretical science to gain experience in application of the theory they're studying. In general, universities are not vocational schools whose main concern is placing students in open jobs. Rather, they're centers for learning. This hasn't stopped universities from creating colleges of engineering, whose primary concern is very vocational. This is also great. Regarding the organization of Computer Science and Software Engineering Departments in most universities (not CMU), I think the Computer Science Department should be in a "College of Science" and the Software Engineering Department" should be in a "College of Engineering". That way, Computer Science students have the clear expectation that the undergraduate program is focused on the study of rigorous theoretical computer science. Electives that focus on industry-application can be housed in the Software Engineering Department. As far as CMU's SCS, the separate institutes, schools, and departments within SCS are divided along the theory and application lines. So I think the expectations are pretty clear.
前几天在reddit看到的一个回答，讲cs在文理学院和工学院的区别 https://www.reddit.com/r/cmu/comments/xmsnxa/would_love_to_see_cmu_cs_ver_of_this_stanford/ Full Disclosure] I am staff, not faculty. I think he's mixed up Computer Science (Process Science) and Software Engineering (practical application of Process Science). ' ---- When I attended undergrad (not CMU), the Computer Science department was housed in the College of Science (Economics, Chemistry, Mathematics, Physics, et cetera). This made sense because it was the mathematical study of theoretical computer science. Sadly they moved the Computer Science department to the College of Engineering and have tried to make it a vocational degree. There's nothing wrong with working in industry, and there's nothing wrong with wanting to specialize within a very large field. However, to prioritize application over theory defeats the study of any science. ' ---- It's up to the student studying any sort of theoretical science to gain experience in application of the theory they're studying. In general, universities are not vocational schools whose main concern is placing students in open jobs. Rather, they're centers for learning. This hasn't stopped universities from creating colleges of engineering, whose primary concern is very vocational. This is also great. Regarding the organization of Computer Science and Software Engineering Departments in most universities (not CMU), I think the Computer Science Department should be in a "College of Science" and the Software Engineering Department" should be in a "College of Engineering". That way, Computer Science students have the clear expectation that the undergraduate program is focused on the study of rigorous theoretical computer science. Electives that focus on industry-application can be housed in the Software Engineering Department. As far as CMU's SCS, the separate institutes, schools, and departments within SCS are divided along the theory and application lines. So I think the expectations are pretty clear. 落地无声 发表于 2022-09-25 18:39
I researched quite a bit when my kid was applying. #) there is not much difference in admission rate between these two. #) NYU is trying to grow the Engineering school's CS, and move professors to Tandon. #) you can switch between these 2 quite easily. #) many CS career fairs are happening in Tandon.
Computer Science (Arts & Science/Courant) Computer Science (Engineering)
还有我一直想问问各位亲，华人论坛可以发可以点开的链接嘛？我每次copy paste都只显示标题。。
哪个录取率更高点？
肯定poly engineering的啊
Courant特别难近！
多谢！我原以为Arts & Science/Courant是文理学院，cs会更容易进些
https://www.reddit.com/r/cmu/comments/xmsnxa/would_love_to_see_cmu_cs_ver_of_this_stanford/
Full Disclosure] I am staff, not faculty. I think he's mixed up Computer Science (Process Science) and Software Engineering (practical application of Process Science). ' ---- When I attended undergrad (not CMU), the Computer Science department was housed in the College of Science (Economics, Chemistry, Mathematics, Physics, et cetera). This made sense because it was the mathematical study of theoretical computer science. Sadly they moved the Computer Science department to the College of Engineering and have tried to make it a vocational degree. There's nothing wrong with working in industry, and there's nothing wrong with wanting to specialize within a very large field. However, to prioritize application over theory defeats the study of any science. ' ---- It's up to the student studying any sort of theoretical science to gain experience in application of the theory they're studying. In general, universities are not vocational schools whose main concern is placing students in open jobs. Rather, they're centers for learning. This hasn't stopped universities from creating colleges of engineering, whose primary concern is very vocational. This is also great. Regarding the organization of Computer Science and Software Engineering Departments in most universities (not CMU), I think the Computer Science Department should be in a "College of Science" and the Software Engineering Department" should be in a "College of Engineering". That way, Computer Science students have the clear expectation that the undergraduate program is focused on the study of rigorous theoretical computer science. Electives that focus on industry-application can be housed in the Software Engineering Department. As far as CMU's SCS, the separate institutes, schools, and departments within SCS are divided along the theory and application lines. So I think the expectations are pretty clear.
谢谢！受教了
Computer Science (Engineering) 做的和硬件没啥关系。
ECE下面倒是有个片硬件的computer engineering 方向，和软件关系不大。
同意每个字