看了很多校园枪击的案例，不知道Michigan Oxford是否算是“好学区”，突然想去查查私立学校是否容易发生枪击，毕竟我家一直设想的是让孩子上公立学校，结果发现，结论是私立学校很少发生枪击事件，那不生二胎转而让独生子女上私立？我知道有美国人家庭是这么做的。看的这个报道的结论可能存在bias，有人怀疑公立学校容易枪击一方面是学校人数太多，一方面是“缺乏基督教信仰”。 Hyewon Kim—a Cato Center for Educational Freedom Intern—compiled information on school shootings in the United States from 2000 to 2018 using the Tribune‐Review database. The database is limited to legitimate school shootings; that is, shootings that occurred on or near a K‑12 school campus while classes were in session or when students were present. The list also excluded suicide‐only incidents. Hyewon found 134 school shootings from 2000 to 2018. Only eight of these occurred in private schools while 122 occurred in public schools. The type of school could not be definitively classified for 4 of the shootings. As shown in the figure below, about 94 percent of the shootings that could be classified occurred in public schools while only about 6 percent occurred in private schools.
Hyewon Kim—a Cato Center for Educational Freedom Intern—compiled information on school shootings in the United States from 2000 to 2018 using the Tribune‐Review database. The database is limited to legitimate school shootings; that is, shootings that occurred on or near a K‑12 school campus while classes were in session or when students were present. The list also excluded suicide‐only incidents. Hyewon found 134 school shootings from 2000 to 2018. Only eight of these occurred in private schools while 122 occurred in public schools. The type of school could not be definitively classified for 4 of the shootings. As shown in the figure below, about 94 percent of the shootings that could be classified occurred in public schools while only about 6 percent occurred in private schools.
那为了孩子安全应该上私立学校？
对我有意义，会重新思考让孩子上哪种学校。自己的宝贝很担心出现危险
你得看有多少孩子上私立学校呀。私立学校的枪击案比例8/134 是6%。要是上私立学校的人数本来就不到全体学生的6%呢
那个研究说私立学校人数占整体比例10%
我打赌mass shooting的枪手家庭信教的超过一多半
134个中，有8个发生在私立学校。然后您又告诉大伙儿私立学校人数占整体比例10%。。。
原来“校园枪击案绝大多数发生在公立学校”的结论是基于这样的数据做出的。。。
有什么可杠的？我的理解是，如果私立学校在全美占比10%，研究中统计的枪击案私立学校占比6%，是否说明私立学校更安全呢？这只是一个讨论帖，可能我数学不好没常识，用得着语气这么呛吗
您如果真不懂，那我就明着说了 - 134个中有8个，这个样本数是完全不能说明是否偏离10%这个比例的，因为样本太小（误差大。）
您要是13400个例子里有800个，说不定还能说明一定问题。
当然啊
这样造成了一个典型的管理能力不足，盲目立规矩，限制好人，不限制坏人的区域。
我们家孩子学校是10分的公立，照样有孩子因为感情纠纷，带枪入校。做为家长非常无奈，弄个防弹书包，死沉死沉的每天孩子背着？
私立学校的孩子大都是rich and stupid，估计不知道怎么开抢