这完全是两码事。这个lawsuit是against Hacienda Health Care的，是民事诉讼。刑事诉讼against那个罪犯和这个没有直接的关系。这个案件中当然是注重这个Health Care的了，主要是讲失职，检查不利，扯那么多罪犯的事对判决的影响根本没用。你现在是让Health Care掏钱，不扯它的失职扯啥？这里和解是指同Hacienda Health Care和解，不是和罪犯和解。 罪犯的惩处是属于刑事公诉，完全是另一个case。
link里面提到好几个settlement，梳理一下： Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Theodore Campagnolo on June 10 approved the $15 million settlement agreement between the family of the incapacitated woman, now 32, and the estate of the physician who cared for her at Hacienda HealthCare — Dr. Phillip Gear Jr. The woman and her family had previously reached a settlement with Arizona for $7.5 million. The lawsuit, filed Dec. 24, 2019, did not name Hacienda HealthCare as a defendant. According to court records, the rape victim and her family settled a claim against Hacienda HealthCare for an undisclosed amount prior to filing their lawsuit. The lawsuit did name two doctors who cared for the woman: Gear and Dr. Thanh Nguyen. Gear surrendered his medical license. The Arizona Medical Board opted not to take any disciplinary action against Nguyen, who reached a confidential settlement with the rape victim and her family.
Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Theodore Campagnolo on June 10 approved the $15 million settlement agreement between the family of the incapacitated woman, now 32, and the estate of the physician who cared for her at Hacienda HealthCare — Dr. Phillip Gear Jr. The woman and her family had previously reached a settlement with Arizona for $7.5 million. The lawsuit, filed Dec. 24, 2019, did not name Hacienda HealthCare as a defendant. According to court records, the rape victim and her family settled a claim against Hacienda HealthCare for an undisclosed amount prior to filing their lawsuit. The lawsuit did name two doctors who cared for the woman: Gear and Dr. Thanh Nguyen. Gear surrendered his medical license. The Arizona Medical Board opted not to take any disciplinary action against Nguyen, who reached a confidential settlement with the rape victim and her family. purplebasil 发表于 2021-06-17 11:42
link里面提到好几个settlement，梳理一下： Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Theodore Campagnolo on June 10 approved the $15 million settlement agreement between the family of the incapacitated woman, now 32, and the estate of the physician who cared for her at Hacienda HealthCare — Dr. Phillip Gear Jr. The woman and her family had previously reached a settlement with Arizona for $7.5 million. The lawsuit, filed Dec. 24, 2019, did not name Hacienda HealthCare as a defendant. According to court records, the rape victim and her family settled a claim against Hacienda HealthCare for an undisclosed amount prior to filing their lawsuit. The lawsuit did name two doctors who cared for the woman: Gear and Dr. Thanh Nguyen. Gear surrendered his medical license. The Arizona Medical Board opted not to take any disciplinary action against Nguyen, who reached a confidential settlement with the rape victim and her family. purplebasil 发表于 2021-06-17 11:42
Hacienda HealthCare is a private, nonprofit facility that houses patients whose care is paid for through the state''s Medicaid program and whose cases are managed by the Arizona Department of Economic Security. The lawsuit accused the state of being "grossly negligent" in monitoring, overseeing and assessing Hacienda''s operations.
Hacienda HealthCare is a private, nonprofit facility that houses patients whose care is paid for through the state''s Medicaid program and whose cases are managed by the Arizona Department of Economic Security. The lawsuit accused the state of being "grossly negligent" in monitoring, overseeing and assessing Hacienda''s operations. purplebasil 发表于 2021-06-17 12:28
不然还能怎样？
是，对她意义不大。
不过，这种判决惩罚性的，这些中心以后会监管得力些。
小孩至少有钱长大了。
完全没说rapist有任何惩罚 rapist还plea not guilty了
那个强奸犯应该还在审吧？不可能说一点惩罚都没有？
强奸犯才应该严惩
不太清楚，希望吧
可惜现实结局差距太大。。
父母应该挺开心的，一下成了千万富翁。他们大凡去关心一下植物人女儿，也不至于连怀孕都不知道。
是啊
Rapist is black.
这完全是两码事。这个lawsuit是against Hacienda Health Care的，是民事诉讼。刑事诉讼against那个罪犯和这个没有直接的关系。这个案件中当然是注重这个Health Care的了，主要是讲失职，检查不利，扯那么多罪犯的事对判决的影响根本没用。你现在是让Health Care掏钱，不扯它的失职扯啥？这里和解是指同Hacienda Health Care和解，不是和罪犯和解。
罪犯的惩处是属于刑事公诉，完全是另一个case。
这是一系列的诉讼，每个案子都是分开的 这家之前已经跟那个中心settle了，拿了一笔钱 （数目不明） 跟另外一个医生也settle了，也拿了一笔钱（数目不明） 还跟Arizona州政府settle了，拿了7.5米 现在这个15米是跟PCP医生 (Dr. Gear) 的 对那个rapist，是另外一个案件，属于 criminal 范畴了，他plea not guilty 不说明任何问题
这家顾的律师够厉害的。
Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Theodore Campagnolo on June 10 approved the $15 million settlement agreement between the family of the incapacitated woman, now 32, and the estate of the physician who cared for her at Hacienda HealthCare — Dr. Phillip Gear Jr.
The woman and her family had previously reached a settlement with Arizona for $7.5 million.
The lawsuit, filed Dec. 24, 2019, did not name Hacienda HealthCare as a defendant. According to court records, the rape victim and her family settled a claim against Hacienda HealthCare for an undisclosed amount prior to filing their lawsuit.
The lawsuit did name two doctors who cared for the woman: Gear and Dr. Thanh Nguyen. Gear surrendered his medical license. The Arizona Medical Board opted not to take any disciplinary action against Nguyen, who reached a confidential settlement with the rape victim and her family.
大案子啊，后面一整套若干个诉讼，肯定会有各大律所争着代理
这个大夫行医执照被吊销了，应该这样，惩罚罪犯其实不那么重要，惩处监管看护人员才是解决问题的关键。加强管理才是保障。
1500万是和医生的和解，假如医生的estate里没那么多钱是不是只能破产了？
医生都有保险，保险公司亏大发了。不过从上面看这大夫执照被吊销了，以后也不好混了。
医生去年12月去世了，7天后那家就起诉要求医生的遗产赔偿，出事后医生就直接退休了，那会67岁，一年后就去世了，一辈子白忙活了…
文章里说这个医生似乎有些健康问题影响他的执业，他需要依靠护士和助手做一些检查和提供一些信息，而且他历史上就出过其他问题
是的 法学院考试，经常给一个案子，学生找有多少被告，什么法条适用 学渣和学霸做出来差别巨大
看来这个医生能力的确有问题，不过是不是这样的机构也找不到能力强的医生？
Hacienda HealthCare is a private, nonprofit facility that houses patients whose care is paid for through the state''s Medicaid program and whose cases are managed by the Arizona Department of Economic Security. The lawsuit accused the state of being "grossly negligent" in monitoring, overseeing and assessing Hacienda''s operations.
是啊，估计压根没去看过i，否则怀孕怎么会看不出来
多谢解答。美国真是个神奇的地方，难怪这么litigious。有空要好好读一下这个案例。
真的好无语 父母和医生居然都没发现
这很正常，美国是个相信体制的国家，穷追猛打一个强奸犯于事无补。最重要的是惩戒那些有责任监管的机构和各人。只有让这些人知道自己的责任和不负责任的下场，才能防止此类事情再犯。
坏人是管教不了的，那就只有管教犯了错误的好人了。美国的法律对于那些破罐子破摔的犯罪分子确实显得有些力不从心，但对于惩戒犯错误（或者白领犯罪）的普通人还是很有效的。
刑事案和民事案分開，一單還一單
这个病人平时一直在轮椅上，查体也不方便，肚子大了估计也不明显，自己又不能说话。这个医生长期看这个病人很多年了，可能平时也没有啥事就是维持用药和每年查体等，再说估计一年也见不到这个病人几次。医生漏掉病人怀孕肯定是不对的，不过这个是特例，不觉得很稀奇。如果是天天照顾病人的家属没有发现病人身体的变化可能更少见一些。
和解 一般都是保险付钱