美国一男子被执行死刑4年后,凶器验出他人DNA

雁过
楼主 (北美华人网)
美国阿肯色州一位非洲裔男子莱德尔·李因谋杀罪被判处死刑,在2017年被执行死刑,他死前一直坚称自己是无辜的,他的家人和一些社会团体也一直在呼吁对案件重新调查。今年4月,莱德尔·李家人的律师团队表示,他们终于收到了对案件证物的检测结果 ,结果显示,当年的凶器上验出了不属于莱德尔·李的DNA。
莱德尔·李:我的遗言将永远是,也一直是,我是一个无辜的人。
行刑前律师曾提对证物进行DNA检测遭拒
据报道,1993年莱德尔·李因涉嫌用木制棍棒杀害女子德布拉·里斯被捕。2年后,莱 德尔被判谋杀罪名成立,于2017年被执行死刑。在被行刑前,莱德尔的律师曾在上诉程序中提出对该案的证物进行DNA检测,然而申请遭到拒绝。莱德尔的律师称,当时法官 表示,有3名目击证人作证称,案发当天看见莱德尔在被害人住所附近出现过,因此DNA检测并不能改变最终的裁定。
此后,包括美国“无罪”项目、美国公民自由联盟等在内的多个组织以及莱德尔·李的家人一直在呼吁对案件重新调查,因为并没有直接证据能够证明莱德尔就是凶手。2020年1月,相关部门终于同意对案件凶器进行DNA检测。今年4月结果出炉,检测显示,凶 器上发现了不明男子的DNA,在当时包裹凶器的血衣上也验出了相同的DNA。目前警方数据库中还未找到与其匹配的DNA。
不过,针对凶器上出现他人的DNA,阿肯色州州长表示,出现不明男子DNA等新证据并不充足,陪审团当年是根据掌握到的证据认定莱德尔有罪的。阿肯色州总检察长也回应称,她支持当年陪审团以及法庭的裁决。
a
aawolverine
关键是验出他的dna没?
m
magnoliaceae
阿肯色那种地方,一点都不奇怪,嗨
b
bigjohn123456
国家地理最近有一期就是讲很多冤案的,好在很多人没判死刑,关几十年又沉冤昭雪了。 对于没有确切证据的,死刑真是一定要慎重。
公用马甲34
最近不是有个坐牢30年的被冤枉陪了几千万?美国司法执行过程中不公正的太多了。
B
Beau
所以从1995年到2017年这段时间警察都干啥了?
k
kajinhachikusho
第一次杀人且只杀一个人不应该判死刑,太容易冤假错案了
B
Beau
第一次杀人且只杀一个人不应该判死刑,太容易冤假错案了
kajinhachikusho 发表于 2021-05-24 15:29

大部分这种情况在美国都没有被判死刑吧,这个为啥判啊?
m
me3
大部分这种情况在美国都没有被判死刑吧,这个为啥判啊?
Beau 发表于 2021-05-24 17:55

因为在阿肯色州?
c
charmanderr
最近国内要爆出什么冤假错案了吗?
n
nurulz
最近国内要爆出什么冤假错案了吗?
charmanderr 发表于 2021-05-24 18:18


神经真敏感
兔子过敏
这就是为什么我支持废除死刑。
虽然有些恶魔,毫无人性,证据确凿,我们恨不得处死他们一千次。但是只要有死刑,就会有被冤枉的。一旦执行了,就再也没法回头了。
h
hijklmn
这我就不懂了,为什么像这种没有直接证据的会判死刑,有些有直接证据的甚至是serial killer的反而不判死刑。。。
N
NJ橘猫
这我就不懂了,为什么像这种没有直接证据的会判死刑,有些有直接证据的甚至是serial killer的反而不判死刑。。。
hijklmn 发表于 2021-05-24 18:29

我也好奇这个
h
hijklmn
最近国内要爆出什么冤假错案了吗?
charmanderr 发表于 2021-05-24 18:18

你这种注册一个月发了700多帖的拿的是哪边的钱?
F
FairCorrect
最近国内要爆出什么冤假错案了吗?
charmanderr 发表于 2021-05-24 18:18

是的,当年错生了你
m
might
Ledell Lee Debra Reese (September 27, 1966 – February 9, 1993), 26 years old at the time of her death, was found dead in 1993 in her home in Jacksonville, Arkansas. She had been strangled and beaten with a small wooden bat her husband had given her for protection. Several of Reese''s neighbors said they saw Lee near the house and identified him to police. He was arrested less than an hour later, allegedly after spending $300 stolen from Reese. Lee was charged with first-degree murder, a capital offense. He was alleged to have struck Debra Reese 36 times with a tire thumper. He was convicted of first-degree murder by the jury and sentenced to death on October 16, 1995. Post-arrest rape convictions and prosecution[edit] After being charged in the murder of Reese, Lee became a suspect in other crimes. He was accused of three sexual assaults, and convicted of two, the 1991 rape of a Jacksonville woman and the 1990 rape of a Jacksonville teenager.[1] He was also prosecuted for the November 1989 rape and murder of 22-year-old Christine Lewis, a mother, in November 1989.[8] Lewis was abducted from her home. She was later raped, strangled, and eventually killed. Her body was found inside a closet at an abandoned home.[8] Lee was tried in 1994; the jury could not reach a verdict.[9] After Lee was convicted and sentenced to death for Reese''s murder, county prosecutors decided against retrying him for the alleged murder of Lewis.[8]
Lee奸杀女邻居,顺便偷走钱,然后被查出曾经犯了3起强奸和奸杀案,其中两桩被认定有罪。
In April 2021, new DNA testing found "unknown male" DNA on the murder weapon and bloody clothes found at the scene.[18] However, the test also "found moderate support" that blood on Lee''s left shoe could have belonged to Reese.[18]
DNA证据显示,Lee的鞋上有受害者的血迹。
k
kajinhachikusho
Ledell Lee Debra Reese (September 27, 1966 – February 9, 1993), 26 years old at the time of her death, was found dead in 1993 in her home in Jacksonville, Arkansas. She had been strangled and beaten with a small wooden bat her husband had given her for protection. Several of Reese''s neighbors said they saw Lee near the house and identified him to police. He was arrested less than an hour later, allegedly after spending $300 stolen from Reese. Lee was charged with first-degree murder, a capital offense. He was alleged to have struck Debra Reese 36 times with a tire thumper. He was convicted of first-degree murder by the jury and sentenced to death on October 16, 1995. Post-arrest rape convictions and prosecution[edit] After being charged in the murder of Reese, Lee became a suspect in other crimes. He was accused of three sexual assaults, and convicted of two, the 1991 rape of a Jacksonville woman and the 1990 rape of a Jacksonville teenager.[1] He was also prosecuted for the November 1989 rape and murder of 22-year-old Christine Lewis, a mother, in November 1989.[8] Lewis was abducted from her home. She was later raped, strangled, and eventually killed. Her body was found inside a closet at an abandoned home.[8] Lee was tried in 1994; the jury could not reach a verdict.[9] After Lee was convicted and sentenced to death for Reese''s murder, county prosecutors decided against retrying him for the alleged murder of Lewis.[8]
Lee奸杀女邻居,顺便偷走钱,然后被查出曾经犯了3起强奸和奸杀案,其中两桩被认定有罪。
In April 2021, new DNA testing found "unknown male" DNA on the murder weapon and bloody clothes found at the scene.[18] However, the test also "found moderate support" that blood on Lee''s left shoe could have belonged to Reese.[18]
DNA证据显示,Lee的鞋上有受害者的血迹。
might 发表于 2021-05-24 18:37

所以说,纯中文的消息基本不能看,只能说某组织能力太强了
a
anzmusic
所以说虽然中国人相信血债血还.但在死邢上真的的要特别小心.一旦实施了就没有回头路.想想当年清朝要死邢那是多么难的一件事. 而王八朝每年杀那么多人究竟有多少是冤枉的呢?
如如
最近国内要爆出什么冤假错案了吗?
charmanderr 发表于 2021-05-24 18:18

瞧你那点出息,还好意思说出来
有dna都拒绝测,为啥啊?难道不该穷尽accessible的证据?或者采纳最有说服力的证据?
人都没了才测,而且还测出来这样的结果💔
s
strawberrykiwi
我在NPR上听过一个案子 一个女生hiker在路上被QJ了 她非常肯定地指认了罪犯 那个人进了监狱 后来有了DNA 才发现对不上 那个人已经在监狱里面呆了很多年 受害者晴天霹雳,完全不知道为什么自己会认错 跟这个人见面,道歉,请求原谅
奇怪的twist来了,这个人监狱里出来不久,又犯案了,QJ另一个女性还把她杀了
NPR说当初警察把这个人放进指认的lineup里面是因为他有一些家暴的前科
.
.岸.
木棍上有别人的DNA,为什么就假定是凶手的DNA,在他之前之后都没人碰过这根棍子?
d
diandianmama
我也好奇这个
NJ橘猫 发表于 2021-05-24 18:31

各个州的法律不一样,律师的水平也决定了你的命运
.
.岸.
他鞋上有被害者的血,赖不掉吧
y
youyichanzi
最近国内要爆出什么冤假错案了吗?
charmanderr 发表于 2021-05-24 18:18

本来想骂层主轮子来捣乱,看了一下楼主的ID,那么层主指出的可能性也还是存在的。
e
elephantdance
所以死刑犯缓期执行是有必要的,毕竟是要剥夺一条生命,一定要郑重。
.
.岸.
所以死刑犯缓期执行是有必要的,毕竟是要剥夺一条生命,一定要郑重。
elephantdance 发表于 2021-05-24 20:18

93年的案子,95年判刑,2017年才执行。还不缓啊,就是不明白为什么前面25年都不测DNA,执行了以后又来测?
c
cannie
非裔被误判的很多。 一个是系统性歧视, 一个是cross racial identification很容易出错。
黑白无常
这我就不懂了,为什么像这种没有直接证据的会判死刑,有些有直接证据的甚至是serial killer的反而不判死刑。。。
hijklmn 发表于 2021-05-24 18:29

真的 这时候那种假模惺惺的人道组织怎么不出来做圣母了?
梅干茶泡饭
是不是他拒绝诉讼的那个deal所以被严判了?
我其实觉得这个东西很瞎的 因为很多恶魔杀人犯和检方达成deal 反而不判死刑
w
welkin25
Ledell Lee Debra Reese (September 27, 1966 – February 9, 1993), 26 years old at the time of her death, was found dead in 1993 in her home in Jacksonville, Arkansas. She had been strangled and beaten with a small wooden bat her husband had given her for protection. Several of Reese''s neighbors said they saw Lee near the house and identified him to police. He was arrested less than an hour later, allegedly after spending $300 stolen from Reese. Lee was charged with first-degree murder, a capital offense. He was alleged to have struck Debra Reese 36 times with a tire thumper. He was convicted of first-degree murder by the jury and sentenced to death on October 16, 1995. Post-arrest rape convictions and prosecution[edit] After being charged in the murder of Reese, Lee became a suspect in other crimes. He was accused of three sexual assaults, and convicted of two, the 1991 rape of a Jacksonville woman and the 1990 rape of a Jacksonville teenager.[1] He was also prosecuted for the November 1989 rape and murder of 22-year-old Christine Lewis, a mother, in November 1989.[8] Lewis was abducted from her home. She was later raped, strangled, and eventually killed. Her body was found inside a closet at an abandoned home.[8] Lee was tried in 1994; the jury could not reach a verdict.[9] After Lee was convicted and sentenced to death for Reese''s murder, county prosecutors decided against retrying him for the alleged murder of Lewis.[8]
Lee奸杀女邻居,顺便偷走钱,然后被查出曾经犯了3起强奸和奸杀案,其中两桩被认定有罪。
In April 2021, new DNA testing found "unknown male" DNA on the murder weapon and bloody clothes found at the scene.[18] However, the test also "found moderate support" that blood on Lee''s left shoe could have belonged to Reese.[18]
DNA证据显示,Lee的鞋上有受害者的血迹。
might 发表于 2021-05-24 18:37

英文 could have belonged to Reese 被你一翻译就笃定是受害者血迹了?
j
jianliu67
这我就不懂了,为什么像这种没有直接证据的会判死刑,有些有直接证据的甚至是serial killer的反而不判死刑。。。
hijklmn 发表于 2021-05-24 18:29

这就是陪审团制度啊。这种形式对陪审员的要求其实很高的。
B
Beau
非裔被误判的很多。 一个是系统性歧视, 一个是cross racial identification很容易出错。
cannie 发表于 2021-05-24 20:22

Steven Avery第一次坐牢也是被指认错误,他还是白人,感觉受害者在情绪激动的情况下记忆也不是很可靠,再加上很多人都不同程度脸盲。
梅干茶泡饭
凶器上没有他的DNA 但是有其他男人的DNA?。。。呃这当初咋判出来的。。。
f
floridapalmtree
所以说,纯中文的消息基本不能看,只能说某组织能力太强了
kajinhachikusho 发表于 2021-05-24 18:47

是的,我看了中文的一般都要找到英文原版再看看