Top reviews from the United States hhhMay 2.0 out of 5 stars Verified Purchase the moral obligation for a documentary maker Reviewed in the United States on November 9, 2019 As a Chinese viewer, I recognized some truth of this documentary. I also feel pain when I saw those infants were killed and deserted. However, I feel the movie itself is a propaganda film. It embodies many clips like military reviewing that was similar to the "Triumph of the will," which only implied that China is run by a centralized government like Nazi Germany. The documentary circled around one-single topic--China is bad and inhuman, and the government tries to do this all over again. Whether this statement is true or not, I do not think a documentary should be this one-sided. China was not the first country to mitigate population and it would not be the last. The thing that is more important than criticizing is to discuss that should government tries to control its population for the greater good. If they should, how could they do it in a better way. I am disappointed to see such a film because I think the filmmaker feel superiority over her Chinese family and most of those her rural relatives. She think that all of them have been mind-washed by the government, but she never tries to understand that every generation is different for a reason. one particular background shapes one particular generation. 694 people found this helpful
我是第一胎独生子女。
我同事也是这样生下来的， 她妈妈都已经被拉去医院了， 结果被前面的产妇引产给吓傻了， 跟着她姥姥连夜逃出了医院， 不敢走大路， 在小路上走。 后来也没有仔细问是在哪里生的。
解释打着道德的旗子也说不通啊 看纪录片独生子女这几十年 这方面咱们应该道德的木有啊 不可能一夜春风重新做人了呀 背后还有啥别的原因？
那些人真的没有人性。被党教育的没了人性
the moral obligation for a documentary maker Reviewed in the United States on November 9, 2019 As a Chinese viewer, I recognized some truth of this documentary. I also feel pain when I saw those infants were killed and deserted. However, I feel the movie itself is a propaganda film. It embodies many clips like military reviewing that was similar to the "Triumph of the will," which only implied that China is run by a centralized government like Nazi Germany. The documentary circled around one-single topic--China is bad and inhuman, and the government tries to do this all over again. Whether this statement is true or not, I do not think a documentary should be this one-sided. China was not the first country to mitigate population and it would not be the last. The thing that is more important than criticizing is to discuss that should government tries to control its population for the greater good. If they should, how could they do it in a better way. I am disappointed to see such a film because I think the filmmaker feel superiority over her Chinese family and most of those her rural relatives. She think that all of them have been mind-washed by the government, but she never tries to understand that every generation is different for a reason. one particular background shapes one particular generation. 694 people found this helpful
这片每次打开prime video都会出现在首页，不过再怎么推荐我也是不敢看的