发信人: wanghaichao (), 信区: Immigration 标 题: O-1被拒 关键字: O-1,被拒 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Thu Jul 2 10:42:01 2020, 美东) 本人博士，现在麻州一家生物公司博后，论文376，审稿40+，3月24日收到RFE，6月19 补交材料，其中包括本公司CTO的推荐信，是1993年诺贝尔生理医学奖。6月30日查到被 拒。什么缘故？ https://www.mitbbs.com/article_t/Immigration/34052473.html https://www.mitbbs.com/article_t/EB23/32795789.html 发信人: xinren2018 (CaiNiao), 信区: EB23 标 题: NIW 被RFE 求助 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Thu Jul 9 00:57:29 2020, 美东) 去年八月份交的NIW I140，TSC，自己DIY的，最近收到RFE，Challenge了所有三个 prongs。特来向大家请教。 我去年申请的时候的基本情况是：1）美国博士学位（博士所在的系在美国排名第一） ，现在一所综合排名80，专业排名15左右的大学做助理教授，工程方向；2）7篇 journal，1篇会议；3）citation 78；4）审稿13；5）几项乱七八糟的奖，例如最佳学 生论文，最佳博士论文，有一篇文章被业内杂志highlight；6）5封很强的推荐信，其 中3封独立的（其中一封来自于一美国工程院院士）7)一项NSF funding (Co-PI)。 收到的RFE如下： The beneficiary intends to work as a Tenure-Track Assistant Professor. In order to establish eligibility, the petitioner must establish that: 1)The beneficiary qualifies for the requested classification; and 2)An exemption from the requirement of a job offer, and thus of a labor certification, is the national interest of the United States. USCIS has designated Matter of Dhanasar, 26&..........Under Dhanasar, USCIS may grant a national interest waiver as a matter of discretion if the petitioner demonstrates by a preponderance of the evidence that: 1) The beneficiary's proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance; 2) The beneficiary is well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor; and 3) On balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification. If these three elements are satisfied, USCIS may approve the national interest waiver as a matter of discretion. The evidence does not establish that 1) The beneficiary's proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance; 2) The beneficiary is well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor; and 3) On balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification. Therefore, USCIS requires additional evidence. National Importance: .....The beneficiary's proposed endeavor has substantial merit; however, the record fails to support the beneficiary's statement that his proposed endeavor is of national importance..... Well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor: The beneficiary has provided documentation of his academic credentials, copies of his academic research and letter of recommendation. The submitted evidence demonstrates you have gained experience in your endeavor. The submitted evidence, however, is insufficient because academic and experiential qualification is only one factor to be considered in determining whether the beneficiary is well-positioned to advance his/her proposed endeavor. Others include whether he/she has shown a record of success in his/her previous work, his/her progress towards achieving his/her proposed endeavor, and the levels of interest in his/her endeavor from relevant individuals. Therefore, please submit evidence to establish that the petitioner is well- positioned to advance the proposed endeavor. Evidence which best establishes that the beneficiary is well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor will document the beneficiary's qualification (skills, experience, and track record), support (financial and otherwise) and commitment (plans and progress) to derive the endeavor forward, and will support projections of future work in the proposed endeavor. ...... On balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification: ....The record fails to demonstrate that it would be impractical either for the beneficiary to secure a job offer or for the petitioner to obtain a labor certification; that even assuming that other qualified U.S. workers are available, the United States would still benefit from the beneficiary's contributions; that the national interest in the beneficiary's contributions is sufficiently urgent to warrant forgoing the labor certification process; and that on balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification. 请大家帮忙给点建议，该如何回复这几三条。不胜感激！！
回复 2楼richey的帖子 大纪元之类的吧 空军学者，签证欺诈来到斯坦福，不知道又搞定哪位白大人？现在粗事了，面临最高10年监狱，25万刀罚款 Feds say visiting Stanford researcher concealed ties to Chinese military A visiting Stanford University researcher has been charged with visa fraud for allegedly concealing her job as a member of the Chinese military. Song Chen, 38, got a J-1 visa meant for work- and study-based exchange programs, supposedly as a neurologist interested in studying brain disease. In her November 2018 application, Song said she had served in the Chinese military from 2000-2011 and that she was currently employed by Xi Diaoyutai Hospital in Beijing. She entered the U.S. two days before Christmas 2018. But according to a statement released by the U.S. Department of Justice on Monday, that was a lie. Instead, the agency alleges, an investigation by the FBI uncovered that Song was really an active member of the military and the hospital story was just a cover. According to an affidavit, online research articles that listed her as a co- author suggest she is affiliated with the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) Air Force. And she was named as late as July 13 as an attending physician in the neurology department at the PLA Air Force General Hospital, which shares an address with the hospital listed on her visa application. On June 21 of this year, Song also allegedly deleted a folder on her external hard drive labeled, in Chinese, “2018 Visiting School Important Information,” which included a letter she wrote to the Chinese Consulate in New York explaining that she was planning to extend her stay in the U.S. and that because the hospital listed on her original application was a false front, she had instead gotten approval to stay from the Chinese military. Song appeared in court Monday to face the charge and is scheduled to appear again Tuesday for proceedings connected to her detention. She faces up to 10 years in prison and a fine of $250,000. Attempts to reach Song were not immediately successful. Stanford declined to answer questions about when it became aware of the allegations, saying only “we have no information beyond what is in the DOJ release.” 空军总医院的医生成了间谍
隐瞒解放军身分 史丹福中国访问学者被控“签证诈骗” 记者颜伶如╱综合报导 2020年07月20日 21:40
中国籍访问学者宋辰(Song Chen，译音)隐瞒身为解放军现役成员的事实，已遭签证诈骗刑事罪名起诉。(取自推特)
加州北区联邦检察官安德森(David L. Anderson)与联邦调查局(FBI)旧金山分局特别探员班尼特(John Bennett)联合宣布，中国籍访问学者宋辰(Song Chen，音译)隐瞒身为解放军现役成员的事实，已遭签证诈骗刑事罪名起诉。
宋辰20日上午在加州北区联邦法院首度出庭，审亚裔联邦法官莎莉‧金(SallieKim)负责审理。如果定罪，她面临10年以上徒刑及25万元罚款。
根据联邦检察官提控书，38岁的宋辰2018年12月23日持J-1非移民签证入境美国。J-1签证是为从事学术交流计画的外国访问学者提供，宋辰是在2018年11月递交签证申请。
联邦检察官指出，宋辰在签证申请书上写着，她曾在中国军方服役，期间为2000年9月1日至2011年6月30日，现任雇主为“西钓鱼台医院”，地址为“北京市阜成路30号，邮政编码100142”。宋辰描述她的职业为神经科医师，到美国是为了在史丹福大学(Stanford University)研究脑部疾病。
提控书中指出，宋辰在签证申请时提供的资料，全为谎言，她入境美国时仍为解放军现役成员，填写的雇主资料只是做为身分掩护。
根据联邦检察官调查，宋辰提供给史丹福大学的履历表上，列举了她与其他学者联名发表的研究报告，但透过网络公开数据库搜查显示，宋辰与解放军空军旗下组织关系密切，而她在签证申请表上填写的工作地点，地址其实就是解放军空军总医院。
检方持法院搜索令搜查宋辰的外接硬盘，发现她在今年6月21日删除、中文名称为“2018访问学校重要资讯”的档案夹，其中包括她写给中国驻纽约领事馆的信函。
宋辰在信中解释在美国的研究计画需要延期一年，并写道北京“西钓鱼台医院”只是用来办签证的幌子，必须透过解放军空军及第四军医大学办理手续才行，并称军方核发的文件属于机密资料，无法透过网络传送。
本人博士，现在麻州一家生物公司博后，论文376，审稿40+，3月24日收到RFE，6月19 补交材料，其中包括本公司CTO的推荐信，是1993年诺贝尔生理医学奖。6月30日查到被 拒。什么缘故？ https://www.mitbbs.com/article_t/Immigration/34052473.html
https://www.mitbbs.com/article_t/EB23/32795789.html 发信人: xinren2018 (CaiNiao), 信区: EB23 标 题: NIW 被RFE 求助 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Thu Jul 9 00:57:29 2020, 美东)
去年八月份交的NIW I140，TSC，自己DIY的，最近收到RFE，Challenge了所有三个 prongs。特来向大家请教。
我去年申请的时候的基本情况是：1）美国博士学位（博士所在的系在美国排名第一） ，现在一所综合排名80，专业排名15左右的大学做助理教授，工程方向；2）7篇 journal，1篇会议；3）citation 78；4）审稿13；5）几项乱七八糟的奖，例如最佳学 生论文，最佳博士论文，有一篇文章被业内杂志highlight；6）5封很强的推荐信，其 中3封独立的（其中一封来自于一美国工程院院士）7)一项NSF funding (Co-PI)。
收到的RFE如下：
The beneficiary intends to work as a Tenure-Track Assistant Professor.
In order to establish eligibility, the petitioner must establish that: 1)The beneficiary qualifies for the requested classification; and 2)An exemption from the requirement of a job offer, and thus of a labor certification, is the national interest of the United States.
USCIS has designated Matter of Dhanasar, 26&..........Under Dhanasar, USCIS may grant a national interest waiver as a matter of discretion if the petitioner demonstrates by a preponderance of the evidence that: 1) The beneficiary's proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance; 2) The beneficiary is well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor; and 3) On balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification.
If these three elements are satisfied, USCIS may approve the national interest waiver as a matter of discretion.
The evidence does not establish that
1) The beneficiary's proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance; 2) The beneficiary is well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor; and 3) On balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification.
Therefore, USCIS requires additional evidence.
National Importance: .....The beneficiary's proposed endeavor has substantial merit; however, the record fails to support the beneficiary's statement that his proposed endeavor is of national importance.....
Well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor:
The beneficiary has provided documentation of his academic credentials, copies of his academic research and letter of recommendation. The submitted evidence demonstrates you have gained experience in your endeavor. The submitted evidence, however, is insufficient because academic and experiential qualification is only one factor to be considered in determining whether the beneficiary is well-positioned to advance his/her proposed endeavor. Others include whether he/she has shown a record of success in his/her previous work, his/her progress towards achieving his/her proposed endeavor, and the levels of interest in his/her endeavor from relevant individuals.
Therefore, please submit evidence to establish that the petitioner is well- positioned to advance the proposed endeavor. Evidence which best establishes that the beneficiary is well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor will document the beneficiary's qualification (skills, experience, and track record), support (financial and otherwise) and commitment (plans and progress) to derive the endeavor forward, and will support projections of future work in the proposed endeavor. ......
On balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification:
....The record fails to demonstrate that it would be impractical either for the beneficiary to secure a job offer or for the petitioner to obtain a labor certification; that even assuming that other qualified U.S. workers are available, the United States would still benefit from the beneficiary's contributions; that the national interest in the beneficiary's contributions is sufficiently urgent to warrant forgoing the labor certification process; and that on balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification.
请大家帮忙给点建议，该如何回复这几三条。不胜感激！！
大纪元之类的吧
空军学者，签证欺诈来到斯坦福，不知道又搞定哪位白大人？现在粗事了，面临最高10年监狱，25万刀罚款
Feds say visiting Stanford researcher concealed ties to Chinese military
A visiting Stanford University researcher has been charged with visa fraud for allegedly concealing her job as a member of the Chinese military.
Song Chen, 38, got a J-1 visa meant for work- and study-based exchange programs, supposedly as a neurologist interested in studying brain disease.
In her November 2018 application, Song said she had served in the Chinese military from 2000-2011 and that she was currently employed by Xi Diaoyutai Hospital in Beijing. She entered the U.S. two days before Christmas 2018.
But according to a statement released by the U.S. Department of Justice on Monday, that was a lie. Instead, the agency alleges, an investigation by the FBI uncovered that Song was really an active member of the military and the hospital story was just a cover.
According to an affidavit, online research articles that listed her as a co- author suggest she is affiliated with the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) Air Force. And she was named as late as July 13 as an attending physician in the neurology department at the PLA Air Force General Hospital, which shares an address with the hospital listed on her visa application.
On June 21 of this year, Song also allegedly deleted a folder on her external hard drive labeled, in Chinese, “2018 Visiting School Important Information,” which included a letter she wrote to the Chinese Consulate in New York explaining that she was planning to extend her stay in the U.S. and that because the hospital listed on her original application was a false front, she had instead gotten approval to stay from the Chinese military.
Song appeared in court Monday to face the charge and is scheduled to appear again Tuesday for proceedings connected to her detention. She faces up to 10 years in prison and a fine of $250,000.
Attempts to reach Song were not immediately successful.
Stanford declined to answer questions about when it became aware of the allegations, saying only “we have no information beyond what is in the DOJ release.”
空军总医院的医生成了间谍