I'm not sure wether it's worse or better than Episode VIII. This movie is just utter chaos. Pretty much every scene is created for spectacle or heavy-handed characterization. The majority are hamfistedly lifted from the first trilogy. Famous EPIV-VI imagery is crowbared in without any sensitivity for the symbolism. "You like Emporer Palpatine, right?" Disney seems to shout in dispair.
Nothing flows naturally, most events seem to come out of nowhere and aren't explained in the slightest. Kylo Ren needs to find a thingy. Why? Don't ask. look at the flashy lightsaber. The crew finds an ancient weapon that leads to some important thing. Why? They were lucky i guess, it's not important, look at the shiny lights. The screenplay is absolutely predicteable, even the big twist in the middle is a horrible rehash.
The relationships between protagonists feel forced and constructed. Rey and Finn try their best to resemble Han and Leia, but it's done very clumsy and artificial. Not Anakin-Padmé-clumsy, but still far from natural. Lightsabers are swiss army knives for Jedis instead of mystical weapons which should be used with caution. The force is super-powerful, unless the screenplay doesn't want it. Rey jumps around like Super Mario in one scene and struggles heavily to climb a rock in the next. And the humorous scenes mostly fall flat beside some minor exceptions.
There are only a few good bits. The lightsaber battles feel a lot less like some ridiculous dance coreography or circus act, but more like a struggle between two opposing characters. And there is a beautiful homage to Carrie Fisher, which actually felt dear, honest and respectful. But most good ideas here are merely touched on and dropped in favour of more spectacle.
What little of Star Wars magic remained has finally left the screen. It's now a disney amusement ride, just over two hours long. This is Disney in full blown panic mode, solely relying on hype and fan service to generate revenue. At times it seems like J.J. just wanted to be done with it. This is the director, whose dream was to make Star Wars movies! I was dragged in by friends claiming a need for closure, but i left 30 minutes before the end. It felt like i could spend my time in better ways.
Unless you don't give a damn about subtlety, consistency, flow, interesting characters and a lot more central moviemaking guidelines, don't watch this.
I'm not sure wether it's worse or better than Episode VIII. This movie is just utter chaos. Pretty much every scene is created for spectacle or heavy-handed characterization. The majority are hamfistedly lifted from the first trilogy. Famous EPIV-VI imagery is crowbared in without any sensitivity for the symbolism. "You like Emporer Palpatine, right?" Disney seems to shout in dispair.
Nothing flows naturally, most events seem to come out of nowhere and aren't explained in the slightest. Kylo Ren needs to find a thingy. Why? Don't ask. look at the flashy lightsaber. The crew finds an ancient weapon that leads to some important thing. Why? They were lucky i guess, it's not important, look at the shiny lights. The screenplay is absolutely predicteable, even the big twist in the middle is a horrible rehash.
The relationships between protagonists feel forced and constructed. Rey and Finn try their best to resemble Han and Leia, but it's done very clumsy and artificial. Not Anakin-Padmé-clumsy, but still far from natural. Lightsabers are swiss army knives for Jedis instead of mystical weapons which should be used with caution. The force is super-powerful, unless the screenplay doesn't want it. Rey jumps around like Super Mario in one scene and struggles heavily to climb a rock in the next. And the humorous scenes mostly fall flat beside some minor exceptions.
There are only a few good bits. The lightsaber battles feel a lot less like some ridiculous dance coreography or circus act, but more like a struggle between two opposing characters. And there is a beautiful homage to Carrie Fisher, which actually felt dear, honest and respectful. But most good ideas here are merely touched on and dropped in favour of more spectacle.
What little of Star Wars magic remained has finally left the screen. It's now a disney amusement ride, just over two hours long. This is Disney in full blown panic mode, solely relying on hype and fan service to generate revenue. At times it seems like J.J. just wanted to be done with it. This is the director, whose dream was to make Star Wars movies! I was dragged in by friends claiming a need for closure, but i left 30 minutes before the end. It felt like i could spend my time in better ways.
Unless you don't give a damn about subtlety, consistency, flow, interesting characters and a lot more central moviemaking guidelines, don't watch this.
不过后半截有些拉回来了还行。。不过最后莫名其妙的亲在一起，然后消失了 。。。这也太突兀了。谁给说说道理是什么？
我说。。。嗯？！ 星战和保时捷什么关系。连广告也没注意到保时捷
今天以看差评原来是保时捷一起设计的，还加入了很多Tycan新电车的涉及概念。不过保时捷这个广告看不出来这个这钱出的有点冤，。。。。
https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/6pvCtY1saBfxiIMsoOH0PA
最后亲在一起 整个电影院都哗然了。 我是觉得太突兀了，但又觉得有没有资深星战粉知道什么我不知道的 让这个梗合理化。要不然这么处理太烂了。
Who and who 最后亲在一起了?
I'm not sure wether it's worse or better than Episode VIII. This movie is just utter chaos. Pretty much every scene is created for spectacle or heavy-handed characterization. The majority are hamfistedly lifted from the first trilogy. Famous EPIV-VI imagery is crowbared in without any sensitivity for the symbolism. "You like Emporer Palpatine, right?" Disney seems to shout in dispair.
Nothing flows naturally, most events seem to come out of nowhere and aren't explained in the slightest. Kylo Ren needs to find a thingy. Why? Don't ask. look at the flashy lightsaber. The crew finds an ancient weapon that leads to some important thing. Why? They were lucky i guess, it's not important, look at the shiny lights. The screenplay is absolutely predicteable, even the big twist in the middle is a horrible rehash.
The relationships between protagonists feel forced and constructed. Rey and Finn try their best to resemble Han and Leia, but it's done very clumsy and artificial. Not Anakin-Padmé-clumsy, but still far from natural. Lightsabers are swiss army knives for Jedis instead of mystical weapons which should be used with caution. The force is super-powerful, unless the screenplay doesn't want it. Rey jumps around like Super Mario in one scene and struggles heavily to climb a rock in the next. And the humorous scenes mostly fall flat beside some minor exceptions.
There are only a few good bits. The lightsaber battles feel a lot less like some ridiculous dance coreography or circus act, but more like a struggle between two opposing characters. And there is a beautiful homage to Carrie Fisher, which actually felt dear, honest and respectful. But most good ideas here are merely touched on and dropped in favour of more spectacle.
What little of Star Wars magic remained has finally left the screen. It's now a disney amusement ride, just over two hours long. This is Disney in full blown panic mode, solely relying on hype and fan service to generate revenue. At times it seems like J.J. just wanted to be done with it. This is the director, whose dream was to make Star Wars movies! I was dragged in by friends claiming a need for closure, but i left 30 minutes before the end. It felt like i could spend my time in better ways.
Unless you don't give a damn about subtlety, consistency, flow, interesting characters and a lot more central moviemaking guidelines, don't watch this.
黑暗面男一号 和 阳光面女一 。。。。不要骂我剧透哈
Ouch, that sounds really bad.
不知道你的多是多少。。。不过我是觉得足够多了。不过比起bb8第一次出来的那一集，在这部电影里的位置显得有些多余了，存在感不高。
还有蕾伊最后说自己是蕾伊•天行者，那么她和本•索罗的吻是什么意思？这是要玩他们表兄妹乱伦梗还是他们结了婚蕾伊改成了本的姓？
哈哈。。。影评都看不懂为啥抱一起了 我就不去动这个脑子了
骂还是要骂的，因为让人失望了
不过看还是要看的 。。大过节的，娃也没事那么多天。去看看乒乒乓乓的热闹还是可以的
11 楼豆瓣 的解释了 。不过还是突兀。 有交流不需要那么低层次的亲一起吧。在force原力这么高档的层次的交流 怎么最后都要肉体碰撞才能升华？ 太俗 。。。lol
感想二，那个AA亚洲角色打酱油打的好尴尬，每次莫名其妙跑出来丢一句话，让人心里满满都是，”她是谁？她为什么在这里？”
感想三，还好是免费的，要我花钱买票我是不会看的。
免费那么好
复联的宇宙 和 星战的宇宙 我更喜欢星战 ，不过估计你是两个都不喜欢
意义都没啥意义 ，但就是图个乐。陪伴我们成长 甚至变老 那么多年了也
adam driver也是又丑又歪
最近还哪儿哪儿都有他，我看到他海报都绕着走
现在审美太单一了 ，我倒觉得主角样子对他的角色很合适
看星战主要是为了情怀。
他真是又丑又歪，反派嘛丑也正常，但是怎么女主就看上他了？
上一部看完我就后悔花了IMAX的钱 ---发自Huaren 官方 iOS APP
Rouge One我覺得行
因為長的就是背鍋臉，每一集都被打到生活不能自理...
问题是儿子像妈啊，电影里他妈那么美怎么可能儿子长那样？
我家7岁的看的倒是津津有味，原以为他会害怕，结果还好，就是太长了，有点坐不住。
现在的高科技片都是高清，星战不知为啥总是画面粗燥模糊
脸像只土豆
从这点上看更显得星战敷衍圈钱了。CG 每一帧清晰度上一截费用要多多少。
我最讨厌看黑漆漆的电影CG ,其实就是说白了 晚上或者黑暗中的甚至大雾什么电脑渲染成本低，而光亮鲜艳清晰渲染成本高得多。
哇，醍醐灌顶！怪不得啥片子都是黑黢黢黑黢黢，
hp一开始还正常点，
后面几部就没出过太阳。。
星战居然还有人看我挺诧异，
女主男主演到谁家娃了这回？
整个剧情完全不合理，缺乏宏大/严密的塑造。。
莫名其妙就复活了皇帝，而且莫名其妙就在一个巨远的角落里无人知道的建设了一个无敌舰队？？
更不要说整个找坐标的狗血过程。。。。这都哪和哪。。。
最后亲上我倒觉得还合理。。两人很久前就灵魂有沟通。。
两人是整个宇宙原力基因最好的两个家族的后代。。所以原力本身就很契合。。。
男主也是白人啊。他其实跟他爹妈一个都不像。
想起来了去年还是前年就是看睡着了，
今年还需要去睡吗？
真的假的，这个机头设计，好像micro-b USB插头，想把它插起来
我们早上看完都在猜，Fin到底要跟Rey说什么？说他喜欢她吗？Fin在8里面不是和那个亚洲女走得很近吗？这集里又跟那个新的黑女走的近，他到底喜欢谁呀？
Rey和Kylo kiss了我好激动呀，他俩是互相喜欢吧？rey不是说“我会握着你的手，但是Ben的手”吗？
为啥要死一个呢？前面一个小时确实感觉太慢了，不过免费电影还要啥自行车呀。
好在公司发票。
adam driver关政治正确半毛钱的事情，人家明明是影评人的宠儿，奥提都拿过了已经，今年颁奖季又是热门。
Adam Driver是很典型的高级脸，一般是客套话形容不是正统审美观上的帅，但是气质特别。
我看了星战简直路人转粉，觉得他太有魅力了，把他所有的访谈都翻出来看了，哦他还上过ted。人低调，谈吐好，出生蓝领。
里面男的没一个好看。那个黑人也丑的很。
☆ 发自 iPhone 华人一网 1.14.05
我觉得他像木村
是的。
现在审美变了。虽然我不喜欢中国那些瘦瘦的明星，美国这些演员也太壮实了，曲线都快看不到了。
你这确定不是在黑木村吗？？？
没人说他演技不好啊，
但如果不是为了政治正确，怎么会找个与父母长相差那么多的人来演？不就是为了避免金发碧眼男生继续当主角吗？
看看anakin, Luke, leia，看看Han Solo, 再看看Adam, 你觉得这像一家人？
我也一直在等这个答案， 剧完了也没有听到， 估计导演忘了