An Alabama woman who traveled to Syria in 2014 to join ISIS is not a U.S. citizen because she was born to a Tunisian father with diplomatic status, a judge ruled Thursday, according to Buzzfeed News.
Hoda Muthana, 24, said she was born in Hackensack, N.J., and left her home in Alabama with her passport in 2014, but the U.S. government argued she should not be considered a citizen under U.S. and international laws which that hold children of foreign diplomats born in the U.S. are not citizens.
Judge Reggie Walton, a George W. Bush appointee, on the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, also ruled that Muthana’s father would be subject to charges of providing material support to terrorism if he provided financial support to his daughter and her two-year-old son.
Christina Jump, Muthana’s attorney, told the publication the defense was still waiting for Walton’s full order but said there was “likely a basis” for an appeal.
Muthana had previously said she wished to return to the U.S. with her son even if it meant criminal charges.
"I was really young and ignorant," Muthana said in February. "I believe that America gives second chances. I want to return, and I’ll never come back to the Middle East. America can take my passport and I wouldn’t mind.”
The same month, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said Muthana is not a U.S. citizen and will not be allowed back into the country, with President Trump tweeting that he had instructed Pompeo not to admit her.
also ruled that Muthana’s father would be subject to charges of providing material support to terrorism if he provided financial support to his daughter and her two-year-old son.
Once there, she promoted ISIS’s ideology on social media and called on Muslims in America to carry out terrorist attacks. But since her capture she has apologized and said she wanted to come home,
ruled that Muthana’s father would be subject to charges of providing material support to terrorism if he provided financial support to his daughter and her two-year-old son. 这个比较好，小布什指定的法官。
also ruled that Muthana’s father would be subject to charges of providing material support to terrorism if he provided financial support to his daughter and her two-year-old son.
Once there, she promoted ISIS’s ideology on social media and called on Muslims in America to carry out terrorist attacks. But since her capture she has apologized and said she wanted to come home, yshe 发表于 11/14/2019 5:32:41 PM
ruled that Muthana’s father would be subject to charges of providing material support to terrorism if he provided financial support to his daughter and her two-year-old son. 这个比较好，小布什指定的法官。
An Alabama woman who traveled to Syria in 2014 to join ISIS is not a U.S. citizen because she was born to a Tunisian father with diplomatic status, a judge ruled Thursday, according to Buzzfeed News.
Hoda Muthana, 24, said she was born in Hackensack, N.J., and left her home in Alabama with her passport in 2014, but the U.S. government argued she should not be considered a citizen under U.S. and international laws which that hold children of foreign diplomats born in the U.S. are not citizens.
Judge Reggie Walton, a George W. Bush appointee, on the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, also ruled that Muthana’s father would be subject to charges of providing material support to terrorism if he provided financial support to his daughter and her two-year-old son.
Christina Jump, Muthana’s attorney, told the publication the defense was still waiting for Walton’s full order but said there was “likely a basis” for an appeal.
Muthana had previously said she wished to return to the U.S. with her son even if it meant criminal charges.
"I was really young and ignorant," Muthana said in February. "I believe that America gives second chances. I want to return, and I’ll never come back to the Middle East. America can take my passport and I wouldn’t mind.”
The same month, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said Muthana is not a U.S. citizen and will not be allowed back into the country, with President Trump tweeting that he had instructed Pompeo not to admit her.
also ruled that Muthana’s father would be subject to charges of providing material support to terrorism if he provided financial support to his daughter and her two-year-old son.
这个太猛了
Once there, she promoted ISIS’s ideology on social media and called on Muslims in America to carry out terrorist attacks. But since her capture she has apologized and said she wanted to come home,
虽然有可能违宪。。
川普当选以后，美国的法官渐渐恢复些正常的判决了。。。
法官干得好，对于这种人就不应当让她回来，既然选择了就要承担后果，别以什么年轻做借口。在哪儿犯法的，就呆在哪儿受审别回美国还得被纳税人养着。
为啥违宪？按法律，她都不是美国公民。
我觉得既然做了这种事，就别指望能全身而退。
不承认美国国籍就直接拦在外面，承认美国国籍就接过来以叛国和恐怖活动的罪名起诉然后关到关塔那摩去呗。
只要出生在美国土地上，就是美国公民。。
所以这判决肯定是会有争议的。。
当然，哪怕是美国公民，也完全可以按叛国罪，剥夺对方公民权，不让对方回来。。。
叙利亚貌似有好几千的ISIS拿的都是西方各国护照，目前各国都不想接受。。
错了好几处。不是所有生在美国的都有国籍。比如她爸是外交官，她就拿不到国籍。这和14条不冲突。
生在美国的公民，不可以剥夺国籍。归化的，可以剥夺国籍。大体如此。
至于叛国罪啥的， 扯远了。
如果她有美国籍，就很难办，难办很多。她有国籍，你不能把她关到关塔那摩去。当初用关塔那摩，就是因为那里不是美国，可以胡来。她叛国，恐怖活动等等，除非她真干了那些事，否则，她要是就是跑去嫁ISIS生子，你还真不能把她怎么样。
查了一下，你是对的。。
外交官由于本身不归美国管，孩子也没美籍。。
出生公民权对外交官不适用
☆ 发自 iPhone 华人一网 1.14.05
川总吸引了荔波肉们大部分的火力，让正常人能做正常的事，好人一生平安，哈哈
这女的还请得起律师我就觉得比我有钱。
不是的，你搞错了。这是对普通人。持外交护照父母，不受美国管辖，子女应当是外国籍而不是美国籍。
父母是外交官，应当有钱的。
该咋判就咋判。
我一直好奇，剥夺了国籍之后，祖国如果不回收。这类人是去哪儿?
---发自Huaren 官方 iOS APP
要是在加拿大 会想着办法给弄回加...
有的是左臂人权组织替她打官司 绝对免费
此女出生在也门好像
土耳其关了多少isis， 报纸没有报道。
但是土耳其放出来的isis 囚犯已经静悄悄地回到德国，
而且是可以自由行动。
不是有报纸报道的话，老百姓真是不知道的。
原来是不得已啊。
德国指望着他们回德国参军，保家卫国呢
不会违宪，foreign diplomat的小孩在哪里出生都是diplomat国家的公民
必定是共和党指定的法官。民主党法官不仅会让她回美国，还会发钱，美其名曰维护人权，保护妇女儿童。
川普还会继续任命四年。川普卸任后草根再推一个类川普当总统。美国有希望了。
刚看照片我还真以为是omar我说这女的咋又跑去isis了？
这法官太给力了。MAGA
就怕这个。
而且她是被抓以后要求回美国的2， 动机可疑
应该立法。 去给国会议员提个建议。
还应该包括归化公民， 如果拿美国护照干着反美的事， 取消公民权。