median household income是税前还是税后?

公用马甲36
楼主 (北美华人网)
一直很好奇这个median household income是指税前还是税后,google了一下,定义是”household income is adjustable gross income, meaning that it is the income left after tax.“, 但AGI应该算是税前吧,只是减去了401k,医疗等。

查了一下nyc的median income (https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newyorkcountymanhattanboroughnewyork,bronxcountybronxboroughnewyork,queenscountyqueensboroughnewyork,kingscountybrooklynboroughnewyork,richmondcountystatenislandboroughnewyork,newyorkcitynewyork/HSG010218), 曼哈顿只有$79,781, Brooklyn更是只有$52,782。虽然觉得huaren贫困线是夸大了,但实在无法想象只有几万刀收入如何在nyc生存。。。

=========================
Update: 再看了一下说明”Because many households consist of only one person, average household income is usually less than average family income.”, 假设把household income乘以1.5当成是family income,那曼哈顿大约是$119671.5, Brooklyn是$79173.0, 这个数目跟实际的感受更match一点。
a
aliquippa
回复 1楼公用马甲36的帖子

常识,美国说这些没有税后这个概念

你觉得无法想象是被华人贵妇一天到晚七十万贫困线洗了脑
b
bigjohn123
WSJ最近有篇评论文章The Truth About Income Inequality, 比较收入最高的1/5 以及最低的 1/5 跟中间 1/5 的平均。可以看到中产其实不比收入上的穷人好过很多,尤其考虑到工作时间压力,commute时间等额外付出

1. 税前收入:average bottom-quintile household earns only $4,908, while the average top-quintile one earns $295,904, or 60 times as much

2. 税后+吃福利以后: The average top-quintile household pays on average $109,125 in taxes and is left, after taxes and transfer payments, with only 3.8 times as much as the bottom quintile: $194,906 compared with $50,901.

3. The average middle-income household is only 32% better off than the average bottom-quintile households despite earning more than 13 times as much, having 2.5 times as many of prime working-age individuals employed and working more than twice as many hours a week.
公用马甲36
WSJ最近有篇评论文章The Truth About Income Inequality, 比较收入最高的1/5 以及最低的 1/5 跟中间 1/5 的平均

1. 税前收入:average bottom-quintile household earns only $4,908, while the average top-quintile one earns $295,904, or 60 times as much

2. 税后+吃福利以后: The average top-quintile household pays on average $109,125 in taxes and is left, after taxes and transfer payments, with only 3.8 times as much as the bottom quintile: $194,906 compared with $50,901.

3. The average middle-income household is only 32% better off than the average bottom-quintile households despite earning more than 13 times as much, having 2.5 times as many of prime working-age individuals employed and working more than twice as many hours a week.
bigjohn123 发表于 11/9/2019 10:01:48 PM

#2里面的"$50,901"表示吃的福利等价于税后“$50,901”刀么?那真是不如不工作,直接吃福利。。。
大衣被禁
楼主数学不行。应该是46k的福利。
支持楼主不工作直接吃福利!


#2里面的"$50,901"表示吃的福利等价于税后“$50,901”刀么?那真是不如不工作,直接吃福利。。。

公用马甲36 发表于 11/9/2019 10:07:00 PM
b
bigjohn123
楼主数学不行。应该是46k的福利。
支持楼主不工作直接吃福利!

大衣被禁 发表于 11/9/2019 10:10:14 PM


比如在nyc附近的,税前家庭收入10万出头有娃要养要上学的,真没有放弃工作(有W2表的工作)在城里政府楼里吃福利的舒服啊
哈根达斯冰淇淋
Lz要分区看。整个曼哈顿也有很多拿福利住福利房的人。你要是看好区还是不只这个数的。