大家去刷新nature上的那篇文章了吗, 很多comments被删,不接受新的comments,看editor's n

b
babypiggy
楼主 (北美华人网)
 http://www.nature.com/news/why-great-olympic-feats-raise-suspicions-1.11109

EDITOR’S NOTE                                                         
                                             The comments below are a sample of the outrage with
which this news story was greeted. We are sorry that it has offended so
many readers, but we stand by the piece. We strongly reject suggestions
that it was motivated by bias or racism; our intention was to
investigate the science behind a controversy arising from the current
Olympic Games. The first paragraph states that Ye has never had a
positive drug test and notes that much of the discussion of her win “has
been tinged with racial and political undertones”.                                                         
                                             The article is a fair-minded look at a controversy that
we did not initiate. It asks whether new developments in performance
monitoring could dispel the unfortunate suspicions that the most
extraordinary athletic performance raises these days, whatever the
nationality of the athlete.                                                         
                                             We are no longer accepting comments on this news story,
and because of the volume of comments, some early posts have
disappeared. We intentionally deleted only those posts that violated our
Community Guidelines.

[此贴子已经被作者于2012/8/3 11:26:14编辑过]
j
jedi2006
2 楼
典型不要脸的极致。
u
ugling
3 楼
以下是引用jedi2006在8/3/2012 11:25:00 AM的发言:

    
    典型不要脸的极致。
    
k
kreaty
4 楼
editor真没水平
l
lorraineZ
5 楼
以下是引用jedi2006在8/3/2012 11:25:00 AM的发言:

    
    典型不要脸的极致。
    
豆豆in兜兜
6 楼
不要脸的让人无语

以下是引用kreaty在8/3/2012 11:34:00 AM 的发言:

    
    editor真没水平
    


★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.3
哈密瓜
7 楼
简直无耻之极!
j
jiaomin
8 楼
以下是引用jedi2006在8/3/2012 11:25:00 AM的发言:

    
    典型不要脸的极致。
    
l
lyxlyx
9 楼
Donald Guandong Chen这个留言
好棒,不但说了自己的观点,还及时的quote了jiang lai的那篇argument。。。
[此贴子已经被作者于2012/8/3 14:27:24编辑过]
l
lyxlyx
10 楼
呃,好多人都机智的转载了jiang lai的留言,nature也太怂了
c
creme_brulee
11 楼
看第一页咋全是中国人留言了
闪闪山山
12 楼
中国人的留言本来就占多数,而且editor internationally删了一些帖子
d
dididi
13 楼
组成一个facebook的group, dislike nature.看他怎么嚣张
b
baozihaha
14 楼
人就是要自贬身价 我们阻止不了它
堇色
15 楼
以下是引用baozihaha在8/3/2012 2:54:00 PM的发言:

    
    人就是要自贬身价 我们阻止不了它

    
d
divajia
16 楼
 since when nature become kind of like weibo? No comments?!
land of freedom?! Seriously?!
s
sunflowerz
17 楼
怎么样才能让这editor下台?我现在连nature的权威性都开始怀疑了,这不也是造假的一种么?
嫿
嫿
18 楼
该用户帖子内容已被管理员屏蔽
s
seattlema
19 楼
哎。。。unfair unacceptable disappointed。。。