Fleeing Gaza is Impossible

小猪的黄香蕉
楼主 (文学城)

https://www.armstrongeconomics.com/international-news/politics/fleeing-gaza-is-impossible/

Fleeing Gaza is Impossible

     

I support the innocent civilians on both sides. Many do not realize that the people of Palestine cannot flee. This entire situation began after Western meddling in foreign policy when France and Britain decided to send Jewish Europeans to Palestine after World War II. Only 10% of the population was Jewish at this time. On May 15, 1948, Nakba (“catastrophe” in Arabic) occurred amid the rise of the Zionists as there are extremists on both sides. Around 750,000 people or two-thirds of the population were uprooted from their homes and forced to become refugees in a nation they once occupied.

Hundreds of villages were “transferred” or ethnically cleansed of Palestinians during this time. The majority of Palestinians made their home on the Gaza strip, which remains one of the most densely populated areas in the world. Egypt ruled Gaza for nearly 20 years before Israel reclaimed the land in 1967 after the Six-Day War. Numerous Jewish settlements were constructed and they ruled the area for 38 years until foreign pressure led them to withdraw 9,000 settlers and hand over Gaza and parts of the West Bank to Palestine.

Hamas overtook Palestinian leaders for control of Gaza in 2006, and no elections have been held since. Now, over two million Palestinians live within 140 square miles of a heavily militarized territory. Half of the people living in this area are children and teens who have no options for a better life. Fearing Hamas, Israel implemented an air, sea, and land blockade around Gaza in 2007. Nearly all humanitarian groups have asked Israel to repeal or lift this blockade with some describing it as “an open-air prison.”

Israel controls the imports and exports to Palestine. The UN Human Rights Committee permits Israel to block the freedom of movement for Palestinians but “the restrictions must not impair the essence of the right; the relation between the right and restriction, between norm and exception, must not be reversed.” Israel bypasses this basic human right by claiming the rise of Hamas justifies closing off the borders.

Palestine’s economy is in Israel’s hands since it controls all imports and exports. It controls the land that is favorable for agriculture. Unemployment estimates range from 30% to 40% and continue to grow. The World Food Program said 63% of Palestinians are “food insecure,” while the UN believes 65% of the population lives below the poverty line.

So these extremists with nothing to lose spent their entire lives hating their neighbors who live in drastically better conditions. They feel it would be an honor to die fighting for what they believe is a just cause. Both sides see the other as subhuman. The governments, militias, and foreign policy are to blame, but the innocent people on both sides will suffer.

 

L
Lionkingmom
杀了人又来唧唧歪歪扮弱者,左左们就喜欢扮圣母婊白莲花,这种文章真看够了
S
STEMkid
无解,哈马斯和平民混在一起,以色列最多出口恶气,最终还是得放手
小猪的黄香蕉
中东问题确实无解。不止巴以冲突。就算把犹太人民全部安全迁出中东,中东一样战火连天。
小猪的黄香蕉
哈马斯这么没有人性无差别滥杀无辜,只能导致以色列完全封死加沙;导致加沙老百姓生活会很悲惨,又变成滋生下一代哈马斯的温床
小猪的黄香蕉
如此恶性循环,永无宁日
L
Lionkingmom
和美国的黑人问题一样
小猪的黄香蕉
都是结构性问题,无法面对,更难以解决
宝马奔驰
恰好有个国家的外交部长在联大提议美国把南卡和北卡拿出供以色列迁出来建国

    

S
STEMkid
不说别的,文章里说以色列控制所有利农业的土地纯粹是瞎扯。以色列在沙漠气候中能让农业自给自足还出口,靠的是科学灌溉,而且

以色列从加沙定居点撤走后,那些农业大棚什么的都留下来了。哈马斯把这些全毁了,根本不去利用

g
gossipgirl8
战争从来就是残忍。在世界人面前进行了惨无人道的屠杀之后,现在又用文明人的标准讲人权之类很是荒唐可笑。
C
CatcherInTheRye
这个事上,你其实只要把时间线拉长一点,就知道两边都不是东西
婉若
以色列现在就想让加沙消失.但是哈马斯既然敢暴杀,也许做好了陷阱,引诱以军深入?
大西洋里来的人
其实把巴勒斯坦从加沙地带和西岸全迁移到地大的沙特,就近也好安置
小猪的黄香蕉
地形上来看,加沙是沙漠,西岸是山区,以色列是控制了那里相对农耕条件最好的土地,这个没有疑问吧
S
STEMkid
特拉维夫以前就是沙漠,被人工改造了呀
w
wandlerland
The land was human made by their technologies

Those farms are used to desert too! After more than 60 years' efforts, those become good farming lands. Jews were trying to provide jobs in Gaza area to eliminate the gaps and help people give up hate. However it proves to be a failure.

小猪的黄香蕉
那怎么办?对加沙来一次Genocide?finish them (per Nikki Haley)?
g
gossipgirl8
LOL,我看过的一篇是讲二战之后给以色列人在欧洲找个地方或者美国阿拉斯加划给都没成,才导致现在中东被阿拉伯国家包围。
g
gossipgirl8
能有什么办法。世仇无解。
C
CatcherInTheRye
那是, 欧裔白人怎么会把自己地盘拿出来,呵呵

都是抛头颅洒热血抢来的,怎么可能给他们讨厌的犹太人。

 

小猪的黄香蕉
好像提议过在阿根廷买块地,被以色列否决掉了
大西洋里来的人
你不能这么看问题。二战日本时间线拉到原子弹落下时,很多觉得是战争牺牲者;时间线往前拉到南京陷落,三十万生灵涂炭时,是什么
兔快跑吧
时间拉长一点,美国人是杀印第安人的邪恶帝国,中国人把周围民族包括自己人杀个遍,都不是好东西?
大西洋里来的人
主要是犹太民族自己不愿远离故土,巴勒斯坦人也不会同意被迁移
小猪的黄香蕉
这个就是见仁见智了。据说,埃及情报机构事先很多次通报过以色列总理可能会有大事发生,但是以色列选择ignore
C
CatcherInTheRye
以色列把所有好点的地占了是事实
c
chiclady
照你的逻辑,把时间拉长,希特勒也不是罪人,是个baby
S
STEMkid
宗教的原因,经书里说犹太人最终会回到圣地
C
CatcherInTheRye
你说的不正说明不能选择地看问题吗
C
CatcherInTheRye
他一度是个baby是个事实, 这要否定吗? 你为政治搞笑了
S
STEMkid
好不好全凭一张嘴。好的话怎么以前没人在那里种地?以色列人开始在那儿种地了才站出来说
r
randomness
这个没法想吧?两百万人怎么消失呢。
S
STEMkid
把那些所谓好地交给哈马斯,他们也不会去发展农业的,加沙就是例子
小猪的黄香蕉
Nikki Haley说了,finish them
小猪的黄香蕉
是的,哈马斯除了仇恨只剩仇恨
y
yhr
是这样。
r
randomness
这。。。
P
Pilsung
估计以色列也会损失10万人以上。这帮哈马斯知道这是开启自杀性质的武力单挑,没有回头路。而且哈马斯看着沙特

要跟以色列结盟,以后犹太人居然跟穆斯林成了盟友了。这是他们最绝望和反对的。这么一弄,他们以后从阿拉伯国家得到的金钱援助就会很少,也买不了武器继续斗争。所以他们会急了,不顾一切后果的去打击以色列。而且这个加沙跟我们休斯顿差不多大,藏了这么多极端分子,怎么找,只能夷平了。而且哈马斯在巷战时候,肯定也弄了很多地雷陷阱,以色列也会死不少士兵。

小猪的黄香蕉
两百万平民跟着陪葬?你也够狠的 lol
小猪的黄香蕉
我们大美帝国总统候选人。。。
P
Pilsung
现在以色列不会停止冲突的。都杀红眼了,处于战争状态了。
z
zaocha2002
所以我猜测不会巷战就是平夷
L
Lionkingmom
结构性问题也是人种问题
小猪的黄香蕉
先放不放平民离开?放的话怎么甄别?it takes forever. 不放的话就是战争罪
大西洋里来的人
所以只能一码归一码。目前以在报复哈马斯的血腥恐怖袭击很合理啊。没什么两边各打一板的说法
大西洋里来的人
所以只需要关注希特勒是个屠夫,哈马斯是恐怖分子,没意见吧?