好消息,物理老师和几何老师不会失业!

x
xiaxie8
楼主 (北美华人网)
现有AI的图片解析能力远不如中学生!
请看附图,从F=ma竞赛网站往年题目中截屏,ChatGPT无法正确读取力臂长度,导致计算完全错误!虽然它最后蒙对了答案B。
To solve this problem, we need to analyze the torques about the pivots to ensure the system is in equilibrium. Let''s go through it step by step.
Step 1: Analyze the Left Rod The left rod is subject to: A downward force FF at its left end, 2 m from its pivot. A contact force TT at the point where the two rods touch, 0.5 m from the pivot. For equilibrium of torques around the pivot of the left rod: F×2=T×0.5F \times 2 = T \times 0.5T=2F0.5=4FT = \frac{2F}{0.5} = 4F
Step 2: Analyze the Right Rod The right rod is subject to: The contact force T=4FT = 4F at the touching point, 0.5 m from its pivot. An upward force F′F'' at the right end, 2 m from its pivot. For equilibrium of torques around the pivot of the right rod: T×0.5=F′×2T \times 0.5 = F'' \times 24F×0.5=F′×24F \times 0.5 = F'' \times 22F=2F′2F = 2F''F′=FF'' = F
Final Answer: The force F′F'' required to keep the system in equilibrium is FF. However, since this doesn''t match any option, let''s double-check the options. The closest choice is (B) F/2F/2, but the calculations point to FF. This discrepancy might be due to a typo or misinterpretation in the problem statement. If you''d like to explore further or double-check any step, let me know!
x
xiaxie8
回复 1楼 xiaxie8 的帖子
再看看DeepSeek如何解答。
ChatGPT几秒钟就读完了图片,但DeepSeek花了将近1分钟才读完图片,然后计算过程和最后结果彻底错误!
To solve this problem, we need to analyze the equilibrium of the system of two massless rods connected at their ends and pivoted at certain points. The goal is to find the force \( F' \) required to keep the system in equilibrium when a force \( F \) is applied at the left end of the left rod.
### Step 1: Understand the System
- **Left Rod**: Pivoted at a point 2 meters from the left end where force \( F \) is applied. The other end of the left rod is 0.5 meters from the pivot. - **Right Rod**: Pivoted at a point 1 meter from the end where force \( F' \) is applied. The other end of the right rod is 2 meters from the pivot.
### Step 2: Analyze Torques
For the system to be in equilibrium, the sum of the torques about any pivot point must be zero.
#### Torque due to Force \( F \) on the Left Rod
The torque \( \tau_F \) due to force \( F \) about the pivot of the left rod is: \[ \tau_F = F \times 2\,\text{m} \]
#### Torque due to Force \( F' \) on the Right Rod
The torque \( \tau_{F'} \) due to force \( F' \) about the pivot of the right rod is: \[ \tau_{F'} = F' \times 1\,\text{m} \]
### Step 3: Equilibrium Condition
Since the rods are connected and the system is in equilibrium, the torques must balance each other. Therefore: \[ \tau_F = \tau_{F'} \] \[ F \times 2\,\text{m} = F' \times 1\,\text{m} \]
### Step 4: Solve for \( F' \)
Rearranging the equation to solve for \( F' \): \[ F' = \frac{F \times 2\,\text{m}}{1\,\text{m}} \] \[ F' = 2F \]
### Conclusion
The force \( F' \) required to keep the system in equilibrium is \( 2F \). Therefore, the correct answer is:
**(E) \( 2F \)**
k
kikidelivery
去了解一下做IMO的AlphaGeometry吧
a
adda
不光几何,数学老师,只要不是calculator级别的,都不会失业。ChapGTP出的错误不要太多,而且给他纠正半天一点儿用都没有。不过它非常有礼貌。
混凝土举人
这方面短板会很快补上的
h
hhxx89
你也说了 “现有”
l
laqyx6
人工智能迭代速度超快,chatGPT刚出来时让它做微积分很多错误,现在已经没问题了。
s
shanggj
回复 1楼 xiaxie8 的帖子
chatGPT o1
一个用户
你对Ai的发展速度一无所知。
e
ezf
好思路
s
scheine
您用的哪个版本ChatGPT啊?o3-mini做今年的AIME II,都能93%的准确率了。AlphaGeometry去年就IMO金牌水平了。 https://matharena.ai/
j
jogging
要穷举的都不太行,比如算24点
x
xiaxie8
您用的哪个版本ChatGPT啊?o3-mini做今年的AIME II,都能93%的准确率了。AlphaGeometry去年就IMO金牌水平了。 https://matharena.ai/
scheine 发表于 2025-02-17 11:01

Free edition.
https://chatgpt.com/
J
Jaelynleaf
adda 发表于 2025-02-17 07:23
不光几何,数学老师,只要不是calculator级别的,都不会失业。ChapGTP出的错误不要太多,而且给他纠正半天一点儿用都没有。不过它非常有礼貌。

简单
你确定?AI24/7在学习呢!