股市不稳,把现金放在fidelity的brokerage cd,是个好主意吗?有坑吗?

G
Grace302
楼主 (北美华人网)
最近在研究fidelity的brokerage cd,看起来太好了。
有FDIC保险,利率还高,这么好的事情,怎么就觉得不真实呢。
和各大银行的cd一比较,真是too good to be true, 有潜在的坑吗?


c
caribou
回复 1楼Grace302的帖子
现在利率多少?
m
mitbbsembassy
万一急需套现的时候,流动性可能不好(没有买家)
j
jpbabyking
我也想知道
w
wintergreen457
买美国国债就行, 现在有的国债比CD还高, 看这就知道了
https://fixedincome.fidelity.com/ftgw/fi/FILanding
y
yoshi
利率有多少啊?求link?

G
Grace302
利率有多少啊?求link?


yoshi 发表于 2022-06-21 10:22

似乎需要登陆进入fidelity的账户才能看到各个cd的利率。
g
goodluckall
回复 5楼wintergreen457的帖子
几年期的?
s
steve888
https://www.fidelity.com/fixed-income-bonds/cds 自己点看Risks。Fidelity是可靠的,但是他只是二传手。本金肯定不会丢,除非你提前支取。利息不一定能够保证。 就是本金买了保险的普通债权,包装出来一个新名字。
w
wintergreen457
回复 5楼wintergreen457的帖子
几年期的?
goodluckall 发表于 2022-06-21 10:26

国债一年2.96, 两年3.23, 三年3.40, CD一年2.9, 两年3.25, 三年3.40. 有的CD是callable, 还不如国债
w
wintergreen457
https://www.fidelity.com/fixed-income-bonds/cds 自己点看Risks。Fidelity是可靠的,但是他只是二传手。本金肯定不会丢,除非你提前支取。利息不一定能够保证。 就是本金买了保险的普通债权,包装出来一个新名字。

steve888 发表于 2022-06-21 10:28

如果说不提前卖,国债利息是肯定保证的, CD也是,除非是callable,被提前结束。
马家majia
国债一年2.96, 两年3.23, 三年3.40, CD一年2.9, 两年3.25, 三年3.40. 有的CD是callable, 还不如国债
wintergreen457 发表于 2022-06-21 10:31

国债怎么买?
w
wintergreen457
国债怎么买?
马家majia 发表于 2022-06-21 10:36

Fidelity
s
smile1234
国债怎么买?
马家majia 发表于 2022-06-21 10:36

国债是Bond吗?国债一年2.96,也是Fidelity的吗?
w
wintergreen457
国债是Bond吗?国债一年2.96,也是Fidelity的吗?
smile1234 发表于 2022-06-21 10:44

是,我在fidelity买的二手国债,明年6月到期。
y
yoshi
还没明白怎么买bond,怎么会有那么多选择啊
y
yoshi
https://fixedincome.fidelity.com/ftgw/fi/FIBondDetails?requestType=&displayFormat=TABLE&cusip=912810EM6&ordersystem=TORD&preferenceName=
懂行的给解释一下? 谢谢
今生无悔
是,我在fidelity买的二手国债,明年6月到期。
wintergreen457 发表于 2022-06-21 10:51

同问怎么在fidelity买国债
s
smile1234
是,我在fidelity买的二手国债,明年6月到期。
wintergreen457 发表于 2022-06-21 10:51

PM你问一个问题了,谢
s
smile1234
还没明白怎么买bond,怎么会有那么多选择啊
yoshi 发表于 2022-06-21 12:08

我看了一下,也是蒙了,太多选择
y
yoshi
还有一个问题,bond到期以后,怎么办?
a
ajassmine
国债一年2.96, 两年3.23, 三年3.40, CD一年2.9, 两年3.25, 三年3.40. 有的CD是callable, 还不如国债
wintergreen457 发表于 2022-06-21 10:31

CD好高 哪个银行一年2.9
s
steve888
买bond和买股票是一样的。政府bond一般到期自动赎回,变成现金存入你的证券账户。
g
gemini2011
回复 1楼Grace302的帖子
要买non-callable的。 只要你不提前取出来,就不会亏钱。 如果你提前取出来,就像股票一样了,如果卖的时候每股跌了50%,那你就亏了50%。
p
pstwo
be very careful ---- I only buy treasury zero coupons, NEW ISSUES that mature 3 months or 1-2 years. (like 3-month T-bills)
There are only 1-4 choices typically.
by the way fidelity cash balance is already like 0.6%.
Buy other treasury bonds may decline in value if sell soon.
https://fixedincome.fidelity.com/ftgw/fi/FILanding


c
calrose
回复 1楼Grace302的帖子
要买non-callable的。 只要你不提前取出来,就不会亏钱。 如果你提前取出来,就像股票一样了,如果卖的时候每股跌了50%,那你就亏了50%。
gemini2011 发表于 2022-06-21 15:22

学习了。这样的话,还是有风险,万一急用钱的话,碰到债券正好跌,就亏了,而CD怎么都不会亏到本金的。
p
pstwo
treasury bills/notes save on state tax & city tax

w
wintergreen457
学习了。这样的话,还是有风险,万一急用钱的话,碰到债券正好跌,就亏了,而CD怎么都不会亏到本金的。
calrose 发表于 2022-06-21 15:29

如果要提前卖掉CD, 也一样可能亏掉本金。
w
wintergreen457
be very careful ---- I only buy treasury zero coupons, NEW ISSUES that mature 3 months or 1-2 years. (like 3-month T-bills)
There are only 1-4 choices typically.
by the way fidelity cash balance is already like 0.6%.
Buy other treasury bonds may decline in value if sell soon.
https://fixedincome.fidelity.com/ftgw/fi/FILanding



pstwo 发表于 2022-06-21 15:29

Fidelity 是registered brokerage, 即使破产客户的钱也是不能动的。最近要破产的crypto brokerage 是没有这样的保证的。何况Fidelity的破产可能我认为不存在。
p
pstwo
Fidelity 是registered brokerage, 即使破产客户的钱也是不能动的。最近要破产的crypto brokerage 是没有这样的保证的。何况Fidelity的破产可能我认为不存在。
wintergreen457 发表于 2022-06-21 15:37

yes Fidelity is good. I mean I like buying new treasuries from Fidelity. I don't like second-hand treasuries .... But their interests rates are a little higher than zero-coupons ... don't know why

p
pstwo
yes Fidelity is good. I mean I like buying new treasuries from Fidelity. I don't like second-hand treasuries .... But their interests rates are a little higher than zero-coupons ... don't know why


pstwo 发表于 2022-06-21 15:42

seems not everybody knows zeros coupons ... example: you pay $99 for a $100 6-month treasury now at Fidelity, and after 6 months it becomes $100 in your Fidelity acct. The $1 is interest and will be in 1099, State & City tax free.



w
wintergreen457
seems not everybody knows zeros coupons ... example: you pay $99 for a $100 6-month treasury now at Fidelity, and after 6 months it becomes $100 in your Fidelity acct. The $1 is interest and will be in 1099, State & City tax free.




pstwo 发表于 2022-06-21 15:45

This is why US treasury is better than CDs. Right now the yield of US treasury is pretty much the same as CDs, sometimes even better. This doesn’t happen often.
y
yoshi
be very careful ---- I only buy treasury zero coupons, NEW ISSUES that mature 3 months or 1-2 years. (like 3-month T-bills)
There are only 1-4 choices typically.
by the way fidelity cash balance is already like 0.6%.
Buy other treasury bonds may decline in value if sell soon.
https://fixedincome.fidelity.com/ftgw/fi/FILanding



pstwo 发表于 2022-06-21 15:29

thanks
l
luoyuwei
没什么坑。数年前利率还好的时候经常在上面买短期CD,选靠谱的发行行就好,例如中国银行。
w
wintergreen457
yes Fidelity is good. I mean I like buying new treasuries from Fidelity. I don't like second-hand treasuries .... But their interests rates are a little higher than zero-coupons ... don't know why


pstwo 发表于 2022-06-21 15:42

Zero coupon has tax advantage: no state and local tax, so its yield is lower. If you count tax benefits, there is not much difference between zero coupon and non-zero coupon. People know math.
半个马和甲
Muni bond anyone ? Why all focused on t bill ?
c
cottonfield
回复 1楼Grace302的帖子
一直在买,觉得挺好。
栈桥风光好
回复 22楼ajassmine的帖子
同问,哪个银行2.9
w
wintergreen457
回复 22楼ajassmine的帖子
同问,哪个银行2.9
栈桥风光好 发表于 2022-06-21 16:40

From Fidelity web site:
Beal Bank USA, maturity date: 6/28/2023, coupon: 2.9%
f
fath2012
好贴,学到不少了
p
pstwo
Muni bond anyone ? Why all focused on t bill ?
半个马和甲 发表于 2022-06-21 16:31

I lost $$$$ on MUNI this year; and today Bloomberg news says money are escaping MUNI like mad ....
The huge loss is even more than stocks. The triple-tax-free benefits is nothing compared to huge loss in principal. The Principal may be permanently lost, or need many, many years to recapture
That being said, if you buy MUNI when everybody is crying, you might gain big .....







p
pstwo
Zero coupon has tax advantage: no state and local tax, so its yield is lower. If you count tax benefits, there is not much difference between zero coupon and non-zero coupon. People know math.
wintergreen457 发表于 2022-06-21 15:59

makes sense, thanks a lot
e
erin1111
没人提treasury direct 的 Series I Bond 吗?国债,9.62% 利率。好像到10月份都可以买。当然它好像一年两次调整利息,不知道将来如何,我们先买了点试试。
p
pstwo
没人提treasury direct 的 Series I Bond 吗?国债,9.62% 利率。好像到10月份都可以买。当然它好像一年两次调整利息,不知道将来如何,我们先买了点试试。
erin1111 发表于 2022-06-21 17:13

people know ya, but limit too small --- say for 2 adults + 2 child, you buy total $80K for 2 years with gift box ? here people are talking about maybe 200K or 500K or $5M

C
Confuse
I lost $$$$ on MUNI this year; and today Bloomberg news says money are escaping MUNI like mad ....
The huge loss is even more than stocks. The triple-tax-free benefits is nothing compared to huge loss in principal. The Principal may be permanently lost, or need many, many years to recapture
That being said, if you buy MUNI when everybody is crying, you might gain big .....








pstwo 发表于 2022-06-21 17:07

Why is principal lost?
p
pstwo
Why is principal lost?
Confuse 发表于 2022-06-21 17:22

For example muni etf HYD went from $60 to $54 because of FED raising rates, so 10% is lost .... and may lose more, we don't know, the annual interest only like 4% (tax free, not bad though)
MUNI funds will decrease in value when Fed increase rates, vice versa
Others maybe better than me in explaining this ... can't type Chinese in office


C
Confuse
For example muni etf HYD went from $60 to $54 because of FED raising rates, so 10% is lost .... and may lose more, we don't know, the annual interest only like 4% (tax free, not bad though)
MUNI funds will decrease in value when Fed increase rates, vice versa
Others maybe better than me in explaining this ... can't type Chinese in office



pstwo 发表于 2022-06-21 17:35

i guess that is because you buy 2nd hand and the risk is in price fluctuation?
if you buy from new issue and hold through maturity then there is not the risk of losing principal, right?
p
pstwo
i guess that is because you buy 2nd hand and the risk is in price fluctuation?
if you buy from new issue and hold through maturity then there is not the risk of losing principal, right?
Confuse 发表于 2022-06-21 17:39

You are Correct, but who buys new issue MUNI and hold for 10 years ? We are talking about flexible short-term capital preservation with a little interest ..... and money can be taken out to buy stocks/house when needed ....
你若安好_便是晴天
国债一年2.96, 两年3.23, 三年3.40, CD一年2.9, 两年3.25, 三年3.40. 有的CD是callable, 还不如国债
wintergreen457 发表于 2022-06-21 10:31

哪里买呢?
h
hhxx89
Mark
p
pstwo
哪里买呢?
你若安好_便是晴天 发表于 2022-06-21 18:59

Fidelity 随便买呀,其他券商应该类似
但是买这么久的(一年的比如),要提前拿钱出来,可能有loss (国债)
CD我就不知道了,我以前的CD银行基本不lose 本金,但是要charge 至少三个月利息好像。
Fidelity的CD product 我也不清楚能不能提前取现。

怀
怀念2019
记下了
马家majia
Fidelity 随便买呀,其他券商应该类似
但是买这么久的(一年的比如),要提前拿钱出来,可能有loss (国债)
CD我就不知道了,我以前的CD银行基本不lose 本金,但是要charge 至少三个月利息好像。
Fidelity的CD product 我也不清楚能不能提前取现。


pstwo 发表于 2022-06-21 19:20


为什么要提前取现?可以把应急基金放在saving account
p
pstwo

为什么要提前取现?可以把应急基金放在saving account
马家majia 发表于 2022-06-21 19:23

假设SPY跌到了不抄底说不过去的时候.... 这个时候,即使损失一点点拿出来,也是值得的

D
DaHill
好贴,mark
半个马和甲
You are Correct, but who buys new issue MUNI and hold for 10 years ? We are talking about flexible short-term capital preservation with a little interest ..... and money can be taken out to buy stocks/house when needed ....

pstwo 发表于 2022-06-21 17:45

Well doesn't it make sense to buy new Muni when u have a 30 yr fixed loan of less than 3 percent for 10 years in today's market with the option to sell
Especially if u create a ladder Muni . ?
半个马和甲
回复 54楼pstwo的帖子
问题是不知道底在哪里 还有这次通胀会不会重新197几年那段历史。
所以觉得需要风散投资- bond to preserve stock to gain
p
pstwo
Well doesn''t it make sense to buy new Muni when u have a 30 yr fixed loan of less than 3 percent for 10 years in today''s market with the option to sell
Especially if u create a ladder Muni . ?
半个马和甲 发表于 2022-06-21 20:44

what you said makes sense. but just for the sake of argument, a single MUNI can default and you lose everything .... so will need a basket of MUNIs

p
pstwo
回复 54楼pstwo的帖子
问题是不知道底在哪里 还有这次通胀会不会重新197几年那段历史。
所以觉得需要风散投资- bond to preserve stock to gain
半个马和甲 发表于 2022-06-21 20:47

有道理的。一般的bond跌的没有stock多,在mkt暴跌的时候。除了 2020/03, bond 没有liquidity 。。。。

半个马和甲
回复 59楼pstwo的帖子
恩。为什么买卖二手bond 比买卖股票难这么多啊?
t
trystone
买bond类的etf也行吧,流动性还强。
s
sunnydream
真是看糊涂了,各种推荐,求好心人给个summary教小白如何选择
a
angelina68
真是看糊涂了,各种推荐,求好心人给个summary教小白如何选择
sunnydream 发表于 2022-06-22 08:17

既然是小白就买CD存着吧 选要选美国银行发行的CD,尽量不要选外国银行发的,乌苏战争的时候,所有苏联的东西都冻结了钱也拿不出来。 另外要选不能撤回的。利息是月付,不要选在结束时在一次性付清的。
k
kikidelivery
现在这种情况可以考虑短期(1-3月)CD好随机应变。 Fidelity已有2%的3个月CD了,肉眼可见融资成本越来越高。
m
microsat
国债一年2.96, 两年3.23, 三年3.40, CD一年2.9, 两年3.25, 三年3.40. 有的CD是callable, 还不如国债
wintergreen457 发表于 2022-06-21 10:31

请贴出一个2.96一年的国债。 一次性需要买多少?
有一次只需要买5000元的吗?
W
WithMyHeart
我的理解是broker里面的CD和treasury只要放满本金没risk的,提前拿出来会影响到本金,这点跟银行的CD的penalty不同。