自己不了解不要瞎说，光纽约市公立学校pre-K双语教学就有近百个program，计入K-12 有几百个： Dual Language classes are comprised of 50 percent children whose home language is the target language of the program and 50 percent English-proficient students. Instruction is held in both languages, and students in pre-K Dual Language classes may continue on the Dual Language track in Kindergarten and beyond. In addition to the City’s pre-K Dual Language programs, there are currently 545 bilingual programs across every borough for students in grades K-12. Approximately 200 bilingual programs have opened or expanded since the 2013-14 school year. Bilingual programs are available in schools citywide in 13 languages, serving approximately 40,000 students. Building on this progress, earlier this school year, Chancellor Carranza formally re-named the Division of English Language Learners as the Division of Multilingual Learners in order to honor the value of the hundreds of home languages spoken by New York City public school students. Below is a complete list of pre-K Dual Language sites available in September 2019: Bronx PS 30 Wilton – Spanish (New) The New American Academy at Roberto Clemente State Park – Spanish (New) Bedford Park Elementary School – Spanish (New) Ready Set Learn – Spanish (New) 3467 Ready Set Learn – Spanish (New) Monsignor Boyle Head Start – Spanish (New) Samara Community School – Spanish (Expanding) PS 49 Willis Avenue – Spanish (Current) PS 161 Juan Ponce De Leon School – Spanish (Current) PS 277 – Spanish (Current) PS 138 Samuel Randall – Spanish (Current) PS 73 Bronx – Spanish (Current) PS 109 Sedgwick – Spanish (Current) PS 226 – Spanish (Current) PS 160 Walt Disney – Spanish (Current) Belmont Community Day Care Center – Spanish (Current) Brooklyn PS 46 Edward C. Blum – Spanish (New) PS 147 Isaac Remsen – Japanese (New) PS 124 Silas B. Dutcher – Spanish (New) PS 5 Dr. Ronald McNair – French (New) PS 40 George W. Carver – Spanish (New) Brighter Choices Community School – Spanish (New) PS 238 Anne Sullivan – Spanish (New) All My Children Day Care 10 – Hebrew (New) Charles R. Drew ELC 5 – Haitian-Creole (New) Higher Level – Spanish (New) Kreative Kare Day Care Center – Spanish (New) ABC Plus – Russian (New) Learn and Explore – Russian (New) District 20 Pre-K Center at 7415 Fort Hamilton Parkway – Chinese (New) District 20 Pre-K Center at 140 58th Street – Spanish (New) District 20 Pre-K Center at 21 Bay 11th Street – Chinese (New) PS 9 Teunis G. Bergen – Spanish (Current) PS 54 Samuel C. Barnes – Spanish (Current) PS 133 William A. Butler – Spanish (Current) PS 319 – Spanish (Current) PS 1 The Bergen School – Spanish (Current) PS 15 Patrick F. Daly – Spanish (Current) PS 24 – Spanish (Current) Sunset Park Avenues Elementary School – Spanish (Current) Brooklyn Arts and Sciences Elementary School – Spanish (Current) PS 89 Cypress Hills – Spanish (Current) PS 108 Sal Abbracciamento – Spanish (Current) PS 112 Lefferts Park – Italian (Current) PS 90 Edna Cohen School – Spanish (Current) PS 139 Alexine A. Fenty – Spanish (Current) PS 123 Suydam – Spanish (Current) PS 145 Andrew Jackson – Spanish (Current) PS 151 Lyndon B. Johnson – Spanish (Current) The Little Brooklyn Pre-K Center at 173-177 25th Street – Chinese, Spanish (Current) District 20 Pre-K Center at 1423 62nd Street – Chinese, Spanish (Current) Manhattan PS 163 Alfred E. Smith – Spanish (New) PS 242 The Young Diplomats Magnet Academy – Italian (New) PS 155 William Paca – Spanish (New) PS 5 Ellen Lurie – Spanish (New) PS 48 P.O. Michael J. Buczek – Spanish (New) PS 98 Shorac Kappock – Spanish (New) East Harlem CHS Bilingual Head Start Program – Spanish (New) Saint Elizabeth Pre-Kindergarten – Spanish (New) PS 20 Anna Silver – Chinese, Spanish (Current) PS 188 The Island School – Spanish (Current) PS 1 Alfred E. Smith – Spanish (Current) PS 145 The Bloomingdale School – Russian, Spanish (Current) PS 180 Hugo Newman – Spanish (Current) James Weldon Johnson – Spanish (Current) PS 96 Joseph Lanzetta – Spanish (Current) PS 129 John H. Finely – Spanish (Current) PS 28 Wright Brothers – Spanish (Current) PS 128 Audubon – Spanish (Current) PS/IS 210 Twenty-first Century Academy for Community Leadership – Spanish (Current) Washington Heights Expeditionary Learning School – Spanish (Current) Castle Bridge School – Spanish (Current) Queens PS 19 Marino Jeantet – Spanish (New) PS 29 Queens – Spanish (New) PS 163 Flushing Heights – Chinese (New) PS 197 The Ocean School – Spanish (New) PS 112 Dutch Kills – Spanish (New) PS 127 Aerospace Science Magnet School – Spanish (New) Mi Nuevo Mundo – Spanish (New) Sesame Sprout – Spanish (New) Charles R. Drew ELC 3 – Spanish (New) Little Friends School Sunnyside – Spanish (New) Long Island City YMCA – Spanish (New) Kon Wah Day School – Chinese (New) Home Sweet Home Children’s School – Chinese (New) Atonement Preschool – Spanish (New) Corona Friends – Spanish (New) BWY Preschool – Spanish (New) District 25 Pre-K Center at 123-07 22nd Ave – Spanish (Expanding) Elm Tree Elementary School – Spanish (Current) PS/MS 138 Sunrise – Spanish (Current) PS 17 Henry David Thoreau – Spanish (Current) PS 76 William Hallet – Spanish (Current) Fire Fighter Christopher A. Santora School – Spanish (Current) PS 228 Early Childhood Magnet School of the Arts – Spanish (Current) Ezra Jack Keats Pre-K Center at 153-36 89th Ave – Bengali (Current) District 30 Pre-K Center at 96-10 23rd Avenue – Spanish (Current) District 30 Pre-K Center at 3252 37th Street – Spanish (Current Staten Island Little Smarties Preschool – Russian (New) PS 16 John. J. Driscoll – Spanish (Current) PS 19 The Curtis School – Spanish (Current) PS 22 Graniteville – Spanish (Current) PS 44 Thomas C. Brown – Spanish (Current)
台湾学校里都是国语好嘛？同学之间讲方言是没人管，大陆学校同学之间讲什么回家讲什么也没人管啊。
有一说一，实事求是。
反腐，汉语教学，要赞。 一带一路大撒币，要骂。
我觉得跟人口流动有关，像我家我爸是南方人但从小出去读书工作，加上我妈又是北方人，在家在工作单位都是讲普通话，方言渐渐就讲不好了，一直讲口音很重的普通话，我们这些小孩尽管后来搬去南方学会了方言，但毕竟不是母语，离开那个环境后虽然也会听会讲，但肯定不会主动用方言跟人沟通。现在各大城市里游客外来工作人口都很多，本地跟外来的通婚也很普遍，孩子们就算在家说方言在外面还可能有同学只会说普通话，为了方便交流渐渐地就变成普通话为主了。
最大的推动力不是啥人口流动， 是学校不准学生在学校时说方言， 课间休息都不行， 监管得严。 如果一个小孩从小就建立了说方言等于被惩罚的条件反射， 离开学校也不会说了。
不完全是，后来网上和新闻有把这次集会和民运挂钩的指向，所以老广现在都不敢用广府话这个词儿了，就是和那次的事件有关系
LOL
这个肯定的！
我记得我读中小学时老师讲课都用方言，读课文才转为普通话。
现在的孩子大部分时间在学校，根本听不到老师讲方言，当然也就无从“习惯”听说方言了。
那是因为他们自己的父母就不是上海人是外地人吧
自己不了解不要瞎说，光纽约市公立学校pre-K双语教学就有近百个program，计入K-12 有几百个：
Dual Language classes are comprised of 50 percent children whose home language is the target language of the program and 50 percent English-proficient students. Instruction is held in both languages, and students in pre-K Dual Language classes may continue on the Dual Language track in Kindergarten and beyond. In addition to the City’s pre-K Dual Language programs, there are currently 545 bilingual programs across every borough for students in grades K-12. Approximately 200 bilingual programs have opened or expanded since the 2013-14 school year. Bilingual programs are available in schools citywide in 13 languages, serving approximately 40,000 students. Building on this progress, earlier this school year, Chancellor Carranza formally re-named the Division of English Language Learners as the Division of Multilingual Learners in order to honor the value of the hundreds of home languages spoken by New York City public school students.
Below is a complete list of pre-K Dual Language sites available in September 2019: Bronx PS 30 Wilton – Spanish (New) The New American Academy at Roberto Clemente State Park – Spanish (New) Bedford Park Elementary School – Spanish (New) Ready Set Learn – Spanish (New) 3467 Ready Set Learn – Spanish (New) Monsignor Boyle Head Start – Spanish (New) Samara Community School – Spanish (Expanding) PS 49 Willis Avenue – Spanish (Current) PS 161 Juan Ponce De Leon School – Spanish (Current) PS 277 – Spanish (Current) PS 138 Samuel Randall – Spanish (Current) PS 73 Bronx – Spanish (Current) PS 109 Sedgwick – Spanish (Current) PS 226 – Spanish (Current) PS 160 Walt Disney – Spanish (Current) Belmont Community Day Care Center – Spanish (Current) Brooklyn PS 46 Edward C. Blum – Spanish (New) PS 147 Isaac Remsen – Japanese (New) PS 124 Silas B. Dutcher – Spanish (New) PS 5 Dr. Ronald McNair – French (New) PS 40 George W. Carver – Spanish (New) Brighter Choices Community School – Spanish (New) PS 238 Anne Sullivan – Spanish (New) All My Children Day Care 10 – Hebrew (New) Charles R. Drew ELC 5 – Haitian-Creole (New) Higher Level – Spanish (New) Kreative Kare Day Care Center – Spanish (New) ABC Plus – Russian (New) Learn and Explore – Russian (New) District 20 Pre-K Center at 7415 Fort Hamilton Parkway – Chinese (New) District 20 Pre-K Center at 140 58th Street – Spanish (New) District 20 Pre-K Center at 21 Bay 11th Street – Chinese (New) PS 9 Teunis G. Bergen – Spanish (Current) PS 54 Samuel C. Barnes – Spanish (Current) PS 133 William A. Butler – Spanish (Current) PS 319 – Spanish (Current) PS 1 The Bergen School – Spanish (Current) PS 15 Patrick F. Daly – Spanish (Current) PS 24 – Spanish (Current) Sunset Park Avenues Elementary School – Spanish (Current) Brooklyn Arts and Sciences Elementary School – Spanish (Current) PS 89 Cypress Hills – Spanish (Current) PS 108 Sal Abbracciamento – Spanish (Current) PS 112 Lefferts Park – Italian (Current) PS 90 Edna Cohen School – Spanish (Current) PS 139 Alexine A. Fenty – Spanish (Current) PS 123 Suydam – Spanish (Current) PS 145 Andrew Jackson – Spanish (Current) PS 151 Lyndon B. Johnson – Spanish (Current) The Little Brooklyn Pre-K Center at 173-177 25th Street – Chinese, Spanish (Current) District 20 Pre-K Center at 1423 62nd Street – Chinese, Spanish (Current) Manhattan PS 163 Alfred E. Smith – Spanish (New) PS 242 The Young Diplomats Magnet Academy – Italian (New) PS 155 William Paca – Spanish (New) PS 5 Ellen Lurie – Spanish (New) PS 48 P.O. Michael J. Buczek – Spanish (New) PS 98 Shorac Kappock – Spanish (New) East Harlem CHS Bilingual Head Start Program – Spanish (New) Saint Elizabeth Pre-Kindergarten – Spanish (New) PS 20 Anna Silver – Chinese, Spanish (Current) PS 188 The Island School – Spanish (Current) PS 1 Alfred E. Smith – Spanish (Current) PS 145 The Bloomingdale School – Russian, Spanish (Current) PS 180 Hugo Newman – Spanish (Current) James Weldon Johnson – Spanish (Current) PS 96 Joseph Lanzetta – Spanish (Current) PS 129 John H. Finely – Spanish (Current) PS 28 Wright Brothers – Spanish (Current) PS 128 Audubon – Spanish (Current) PS/IS 210 Twenty-first Century Academy for Community Leadership – Spanish (Current) Washington Heights Expeditionary Learning School – Spanish (Current) Castle Bridge School – Spanish (Current) Queens PS 19 Marino Jeantet – Spanish (New) PS 29 Queens – Spanish (New) PS 163 Flushing Heights – Chinese (New) PS 197 The Ocean School – Spanish (New) PS 112 Dutch Kills – Spanish (New) PS 127 Aerospace Science Magnet School – Spanish (New) Mi Nuevo Mundo – Spanish (New) Sesame Sprout – Spanish (New) Charles R. Drew ELC 3 – Spanish (New) Little Friends School Sunnyside – Spanish (New) Long Island City YMCA – Spanish (New) Kon Wah Day School – Chinese (New) Home Sweet Home Children’s School – Chinese (New) Atonement Preschool – Spanish (New) Corona Friends – Spanish (New) BWY Preschool – Spanish (New) District 25 Pre-K Center at 123-07 22nd Ave – Spanish (Expanding) Elm Tree Elementary School – Spanish (Current) PS/MS 138 Sunrise – Spanish (Current) PS 17 Henry David Thoreau – Spanish (Current) PS 76 William Hallet – Spanish (Current) Fire Fighter Christopher A. Santora School – Spanish (Current) PS 228 Early Childhood Magnet School of the Arts – Spanish (Current) Ezra Jack Keats Pre-K Center at 153-36 89th Ave – Bengali (Current) District 30 Pre-K Center at 96-10 23rd Avenue – Spanish (Current) District 30 Pre-K Center at 3252 37th Street – Spanish (Current Staten Island Little Smarties Preschool – Russian (New) PS 16 John. J. Driscoll – Spanish (Current) PS 19 The Curtis School – Spanish (Current) PS 22 Graniteville – Spanish (Current) PS 44 Thomas C. Brown – Spanish (Current)
公立学校Chinese immersion 班遍地都是。除了英语课，其他学科都用中文教。
孔子他老人家被迫入党，参与大外宣和间谍活动
如果羅馬化的話，確實都有各自的文字⋯蒙語文字也是拼音文字，轉羅馬文字更是毫無困難。
你能看懂维吾尔族的字还是蒙古字？
外蒙用的文字和俄语一个体系的，很接近
假借孔子搞大外宣了，最没资格提孔子的就是现在这任政府了
现在的那一套根本就不是什么汉文化，中国文化，中国的传统文化在他们挖孔子家族的坟的时候就已经被消灭了
你所说的特殊待遇其实根本没有几个受益的蒙古族同学，每年蒙古族读清北的一共才几十个人？这么点小恩小惠然后让全国汉族人民以为这些少数民族有特权了，执政党真是太有手段了。你要是真看人家有没有实际的权利，要看这些地方政府有多少高管是本族人为本族的利益服务。
这个回复可以给反对AA的人也看一看。
就好像这边abc在学校也不说中文，但是只要家里人一直说中文，大部分ABC的中文至少听和说一般都没问题啊
Re: 方言也是一种文化，地域文化，很多方言有自己的文字系统，粤语，蒙古语和藏语就是，上海话也有些汉字有自己的表记，不过现在会写的人不多了，也算是一种地域传统文化的流失吧
虽然这样说不好，但我觉得对你们是很贴切的： 狗喜欢吃屎，所以你们也得喜欢吃屎？
那新疆人犯罪问题不是更严重？
犯不犯罪都會被關進大牢
技能培训，每人先考50个证，确保就业。
蒙古国的蒙语用的是和俄语一样的Cyrillic alphabet, 原因是蒙古独立后沦为了苏俄的satellite state。但现在蒙古国最哈的其实是美国，以后可能会改用Latin alphabet
當年周恩來要是乖乖的搞漢語拚音文字化
不要搞啥簡體化
漢文也不會淪落到今天這樣
平語近人
刘少奇周恩来是想这样搞的(越南语文字给的灵感)，但腊肉出手不凡整跨了刘少奇这些苏俄亲儿子，所以只能搞到简化字这种程度了
都是四匹幫惹的禍啊....
腊肉被刘少奇整死的话，现在的中国可能是继续用Latin alphabet 或者就干脆恢复传统汉字
所以啊
我早就看出來了
列寧體制早晚崩解
還是站在 正體字一邊
比較穩定
这是什么逻辑？ 就因为七五少数民族暴徒杀害无辜汉人， 就支持取消少数民族说自己语言的权利？饭店不许叫清真，少数民族学生必须和汉人同住以便监视？
除非父母双方都来自相同地方方言的家庭，
对我来说，上海话好学，跟人听听就会了，除非几个特殊词
这怎么叫特殊待遇，这是正常的人权，上海人没有就不许别人有？上海人不敢争取别人也得跪着？
同意这个，楼主不像是在西方国家生活很久并认同西方民主平等概念的人，很像是文化大革命被塑性的一代，我没有的你也别想有，这种思维其实在老一辈中国人里非常顽固。
楼里很多洗地的逻辑颠倒，也难为他们了，因为根本洗不白。反过来看，新疆的暴乱其实就是暴政的反映，所有的东西有因有果，为啥只讲暴乱不准讲暴政呢？
就好比香港年轻人暴乱，为什么只讲结果而不讲原因-解放军的残酷镇压，他们无法正常和平发声。
顺着你的思路继续拓展一下，ABC二代的中文其实也要靠家里的教育加持的
从南疆还能翻墙出来，真是难得
广东人武警去香港有有语言障碍？
我们小时候老师上课用普通话，骂我们用方言。后来外地老师多了，轮到我们教他们说方言了。怀念小时候
字体是一样的，但字的意思和句子的组合可以很不一样。举几个字的例子：佢，叻，都是上学没教过的文字，但在广东话里很常见。如果我截图一段广东人的微信对话，不说广东话的人根本摸不着头脑。
Ccp民族政策失败！不能作为灭维族文化的借口啊
什么翻墙 ？ 我在美国 来美十年了 我家人 朋友都还在新疆啊 我侄女在喀什上大学啊 怎么了 我去年暑假回国 她给我说的 平时微信 从不谈这些 毕竟....
蒙古人去新疆干的吗？
哎 真不明白你咋理解的 LZ说 新疆人都可以说维语呢 上海人在学校都不准说上海话了 我只是说个事实 她错了 新疆维吾尔人 在学校不可以说维语的 至少从2018年开始
我家里人都对我侄女说 听见任何人没有说国语 在说自己的本民族语言 千万别听学校的去举报 她们宿舍有三汉三民 其中一个民族女生 会的汉语非常有限 每天话很少 但也不敢用民族话说 毕竟“ 公共场合 是要求国语的” 估计偷偷私下 环顾四周 确定没“外人” 才敢用自己的语言吧
蒙古人是北疆的原住民族群之一，另外就是哈萨克人
支持 教育 管理 某一部分人 同住说是为了互相帮助 清镇二字没了 确实不方便 哎 但并不支持废除语言等 但没有话语权啊 一刀切的命令下来 谁敢不？ 我们朋友 体制内工作的 都在结“亲戚” （ 少数民族） 帮他们学汉语， 找工作， 去年十一大庆， 我刚好回国， 体制内单位的人 ， 长假都不得出疆的， 离开本市， 都要请假， 有领导批条同意才行， 但一般领导不会同意。 十一为了不让你出去浪 隔一天上班 值班 我好朋友就是带着“ 亲戚” 去他们单位 看大庆阅兵直播
哎 不好说
當年廣東高校，中學集體游行，聲勢非常浩大. 新聞不讓報而已.
这样的环境下，人家能真心想融入才怪。还有人说少数民族占便宜。想想人家是什么心情。 蒙古族本来就相安无事，现在也要被逼迫把母语当外语，不气愤才怪。当地的汉人也不会有好结果。
广东粤语和香港人说的粤语有部份不一样
宾语前置
普通话说给你这个，广东人说给这你